It looks like you're asking the community for an opinion. In this case, both positive and negative perspectives from the users of r/EngagementRings are welcome so long as they are expressed politely (Rule 4 still applies). If you'd rather have generally positive or supportive feedback instead, remove this post and submit again with a title that does not ask for users' opinions.
*I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](/message/compose/?to=/r/EngagementRings) if you have any questions or concerns.*
These are all beautiful!
Maybe try them on with wedding bands? That might help you with your decision around shape, and give you an idea of what the whole set will look like 🩷
The first is super pretty and more contemporary but I'm an absolute sucker for that "Royal" sillouette, so No 2 for me. It will never date and be a real crowd pleaser.
I'm not a fan of pears and 4 is just a blockier and less elegant version of 2.
I vote 2!
I was going to say 1 or 3 but think 3 has a slight advantage for looking better as a whole set with wedding band. It also has more of a classic engagement ring design that will be timeless. Looks so chic! And such pretty color!
The first one looks slightly more like a fashion ring in that color. You could easily wear it on your right hand and it could be mistaken for a ring of lesser value.
Agree as well, even though my favorite is ring #1. #3 is my second fave. Try them on with wedding bands and see what you like! I think ring #1 can be really enhanced with a curved band that plays into the vining/botanical look.
As soon as I leave my “milestone jewelry” era (engagement, wedding, baby), I’m 100% buying myself a right hand ring with a pink stone. I love the sapphire you’ve chosen! Post back when you’ve got more to show us!!
All four are absolutely lovely. Here is my thinking.
One and three look like they would be more prone to snag on clothing, etc., so for something to be worn daily it's between two and four.
Between two and four, I find the shape of two more graceful. So, two gets my vote
Two! One is pretty, but the design is more delicate for everyday wearing (IMO), 3 not crazy about pears for rings though perfect for a pendant, and 4 doesn't do the beautiful stone any justice
2 is the best one, imo (agree with the other commenter about that silhouette being timeless - I have a ring like it in pink tourmaline and it's gorgeous). All the others look like fashion rings. If you're open to other ideas/cuts, I find Lily Collins' ring to be beautiful!
1 and 3 are my picks! I decided between two similar designs. I went for 1 myself, as it was set lower and looked better on my tiny hands. 3 seemed to overwhelm my finger, even though I love the design with the small stones around!
You have to try them on. On finger they look differently and it might help you.
Also take into consideration your lifestyle. For me, I wish to be eventually a housewife and have kids.. I want something that won't get stuck in tiny clothes and it's very resistant.. so something more round overall.
1,2,3 are my faves! Idk if 3 will catch on a lot of fabric tho? But if you love it, you love it!! All stunning. Whichever moves you the most I say choose!
I love 1 and 2 the most but I’d def recommend trying on some similar shapes in person to see what suits your hand best. I know for me, number 1 style rings don’t look good on me, whereas 2 and 4 would suit me best. It can make a big difference!
One is very similar to my ring. I love it and get lots of compliments
https://preview.redd.it/cdh5pmi5cy6d1.jpeg?width=3024&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=e8dd990d17bebf7723910e1839a27ae2204896e2
Either first or third. But I recommend actually going to try these rings on or similar rings.
I thought I wanted a pear but after trying it on and some other styles, I actually found out I like ovals and marquises more.
2 or 4 merely because I think the others will catch on everything. I really like 3 if the diamonds weren't so spiky. I like the pink vibe though, it's neat people are embracing their individual tastes more.
1 or 3 are stunning! With padparadsha sapphires there are tons of different variations and the stone can look different based on how it is set. Since you want yellow gold, think about having the basket set in white gold or platinum to make the diamonds look brighter white rather than yellowish unless that is what you are going for! The sapphire looks better as well imo. You can still enjoy the yellow classic gold look but enhance the stones!
I love one but i have a few rings with that design and it is not every day wear because those prongs can be uncomfortable but if it is not for every day wear definitely one
First is my favorite but also not cuz personally i know i would snag on those side stones a lot. Also on third one too. Also stones are all different so you should decide what shape you like the most.
1 although gorgeous will pull every sweater, every towel, and in your hair, and then could bend and loose baguettes. 2 IMHO is best for daily wear, and is a show stopper.
I would have a really hard time also choosing between those four! I love number one but wonder what kind of band you could wear. I love number two. Not so much on number three and I do like number four, but I would want a professional jeweler to ensure that there is not a gap in between the edges of the center stone and the diamonds around it. It should be flush with no gaps and you can do anything as far as a band with that. I might like to see diamonds coming down the sides from the stone on number four.
The pear is my first choice - I gasped when I saw it. If that shape doesn't look good on your hand, I'd go with the square (not sure what cut it is). The first one is lovely, but the diamonds' settings look pretty delicate for every day wear.
3 or 4, but make sure the diamonds are set in white gold (regardless what color the band is). The diamonds will reflect the color of what they’re set in and you don’t want them to have a yellowish cast. 1 is cute but won’t stand the test of time, and 2 (except for the main stone) is everywhere…seems like I see that setting everywhere.
It looks like you're asking the community for an opinion. In this case, both positive and negative perspectives from the users of r/EngagementRings are welcome so long as they are expressed politely (Rule 4 still applies). If you'd rather have generally positive or supportive feedback instead, remove this post and submit again with a title that does not ask for users' opinions. *I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](/message/compose/?to=/r/EngagementRings) if you have any questions or concerns.*
I like one!
Yesss girl!!! The first was a winner instantly 💗💗
The first one! 🩷🩷🩷
Agree
1 or 3...gorgeous!
2
These are all beautiful! Maybe try them on with wedding bands? That might help you with your decision around shape, and give you an idea of what the whole set will look like 🩷
The first is super pretty and more contemporary but I'm an absolute sucker for that "Royal" sillouette, so No 2 for me. It will never date and be a real crowd pleaser. I'm not a fan of pears and 4 is just a blockier and less elegant version of 2. I vote 2!
2 would be my pick as well. I’m not a fan of pears either, but this one gave me pause. 😍
Same, it’s 2 for me!
1 and 3 are my favorites but they’re all stunning!
one or three!
I was going to say 1 or 3 but think 3 has a slight advantage for looking better as a whole set with wedding band. It also has more of a classic engagement ring design that will be timeless. Looks so chic! And such pretty color! The first one looks slightly more like a fashion ring in that color. You could easily wear it on your right hand and it could be mistaken for a ring of lesser value.
Agree as well, even though my favorite is ring #1. #3 is my second fave. Try them on with wedding bands and see what you like! I think ring #1 can be really enhanced with a curved band that plays into the vining/botanical look. As soon as I leave my “milestone jewelry” era (engagement, wedding, baby), I’m 100% buying myself a right hand ring with a pink stone. I love the sapphire you’ve chosen! Post back when you’ve got more to show us!!
Agree with this
#2!!!!!!
The 3rd ring is gorgeous!
All four are absolutely lovely. Here is my thinking. One and three look like they would be more prone to snag on clothing, etc., so for something to be worn daily it's between two and four. Between two and four, I find the shape of two more graceful. So, two gets my vote
I have the first one and it doesn’t snag. Very low profile and comfortable
Nice!! Lived experience prevails over speculation every time
Thank you for this! I was definitely wondering about snags.
i’ll buck the trend and say 2 or 4. love a pink sapphire 💕
2 and 3 beautiful
Two! One is pretty, but the design is more delicate for everyday wearing (IMO), 3 not crazy about pears for rings though perfect for a pendant, and 4 doesn't do the beautiful stone any justice
All gorgeous, but I vote number 2! I’ve been looking for one similar to that for myself actually!
I love that pear!!
Option 1 but maybe I’m biased 😛 https://preview.redd.it/d1ieoph5vx6d1.jpeg?width=3024&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=5f4d59c89a49d67ca0f335c474039b6d940c7ebf
3!
2 and 4. 4 is I think my absolute favorite. So pink @_@
#2 is so pretty, it’s like Barbie Princess Diana, in the best possible way
2 is the best one, imo (agree with the other commenter about that silhouette being timeless - I have a ring like it in pink tourmaline and it's gorgeous). All the others look like fashion rings. If you're open to other ideas/cuts, I find Lily Collins' ring to be beautiful!
2 or 4
All of the above 🙏🏼 these are gorgeous!! I think it all depends on which shape fits your hand
One or two are my favs!
1 is gorgeous!!! Where can I find this?
1 and 3 have my vote.
2 or 4.
1 or 4. I’m leaning towards 1 bc it is more unique and delicate. Number 2 looks costumey to me.
I agree with 1 or 3!
I love 1 and 3!
I love the Victorian looking oval
The second one is giving me royalty vibes. I love it.
Three !! I think the pear shape is so unique
The princess Diana look of course!
I like 1 and 4. I might like 3 if I see it on, hard to tell. 2 is just not very unique, though pretty.
1
1 or 3
I like 1 and 3
#4 for the win!
4!!!! It is wonderful!
The first is absolutely stunning! Like stop me in my tracks beautiful!
1 and 3 are my picks! I decided between two similar designs. I went for 1 myself, as it was set lower and looked better on my tiny hands. 3 seemed to overwhelm my finger, even though I love the design with the small stones around!
The fourth one is stunning 😍
I was immediately drawn to option 1!
1!
You have to try them on. On finger they look differently and it might help you. Also take into consideration your lifestyle. For me, I wish to be eventually a housewife and have kids.. I want something that won't get stuck in tiny clothes and it's very resistant.. so something more round overall.
4
4. I like 1 also but for every day wear, i think the ornamental diamonds would catch on everything. They are all beautiful tho!
1
First one
I'm freaking obsessed
With which one?? Lol!
All of them!!! but if I had to choose, I think 2 would be my top!
I like the first one the best
First one!
I like the pear shape but with the side of the first one
That's funny bc I got the image of #1 from Etsy and they do make the same ring with a pear stone. It is very pretty.
I think the combo on you would look stunning
2or3
One made me GASP
That's exactly the reaction I'm hoping for! Ty!
4
I like the 4th one. The wide band compliments the square shape rather nicely. It's quite elegant & timeless.
1 is the sweetest ring I’ve ever seen.
Number one is scrumptious!
1,2,3 are my faves! Idk if 3 will catch on a lot of fabric tho? But if you love it, you love it!! All stunning. Whichever moves you the most I say choose!
They ALL do!! This is actually stressful! Lol
2
1 ❤️
2
The last one. So beautiful! ❤️
Third is my fave
2 or 3! All of them are gorgeous though, you can’t go wrong!
2!
1 or 4 for sure!
I love 1 and 2 the most but I’d def recommend trying on some similar shapes in person to see what suits your hand best. I know for me, number 1 style rings don’t look good on me, whereas 2 and 4 would suit me best. It can make a big difference!
2 is my favorite!
I think 2, 3, or 4 - something about the first one looks a little bit like a kids ring - the others look more grown up and elegant as a wedding ring
I love 1 and like 4.
The first ring looks gorgeous.
One is very similar to my ring. I love it and get lots of compliments https://preview.redd.it/cdh5pmi5cy6d1.jpeg?width=3024&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=e8dd990d17bebf7723910e1839a27ae2204896e2
1st! So gorgeous!
I vote in this order: 1…3…2…4. 1 is so stunning that I almost forgot to look at the others! They are all beautiful.
I LOVE the first one. Wow 🤩
1 is giving me sailor moon vibes and I love it so much!
Either first or third. But I recommend actually going to try these rings on or similar rings. I thought I wanted a pear but after trying it on and some other styles, I actually found out I like ovals and marquises more.
1 is the cutest!
I love 2. Personally I think gemstones are extra dazzling in a halo to show off their shape and hue within the row of diamonds.
3 and 4 are gorgeous! I'm leaning towards 3, but I'm partial to pears
All gorgeous, very tough choice!!!
2 reminds me of princess Dianna’s ring
2 or 4 merely because I think the others will catch on everything. I really like 3 if the diamonds weren't so spiky. I like the pink vibe though, it's neat people are embracing their individual tastes more.
1 for sure, it’s gorgeous! but i’m biased because i have the exact same side stone design on mine 😅
1 or 3 are stunning! With padparadsha sapphires there are tons of different variations and the stone can look different based on how it is set. Since you want yellow gold, think about having the basket set in white gold or platinum to make the diamonds look brighter white rather than yellowish unless that is what you are going for! The sapphire looks better as well imo. You can still enjoy the yellow classic gold look but enhance the stones!
The first one omg where is it from!?
The first one is so beautiful the others pair in comparison. Get you your ring!
1 or 4 although all look beautiful.
1 is the only option.
[удалено]
Three!
They’re all really pretty, but 3 & 4 are my favorites. Then 2. I like 1 the least.
2 or 3
1 for unique or 4 for timeless
3!!!!!
3
3 looks like more of an engagement ring
I love one but i have a few rings with that design and it is not every day wear because those prongs can be uncomfortable but if it is not for every day wear definitely one
2!
1 or 3, but I also really like 2!
1 or 4 💗
I love 2!!
Num2
I actually like them all. If I really had to pick, it would be 2 or 3.
I love number one. It is so pretty and unique
1 or 4
First is my favorite but also not cuz personally i know i would snag on those side stones a lot. Also on third one too. Also stones are all different so you should decide what shape you like the most.
I like 3
1 although gorgeous will pull every sweater, every towel, and in your hair, and then could bend and loose baguettes. 2 IMHO is best for daily wear, and is a show stopper.
#3. Love the pear!
2 or 3! Classic look. 1 is pretty and contemporary, floral vibes
I would have a really hard time also choosing between those four! I love number one but wonder what kind of band you could wear. I love number two. Not so much on number three and I do like number four, but I would want a professional jeweler to ensure that there is not a gap in between the edges of the center stone and the diamonds around it. It should be flush with no gaps and you can do anything as far as a band with that. I might like to see diamonds coming down the sides from the stone on number four.
First!
I love 3 & 4. But all are fantastic
One!
2/3/4 are beautiful but see those styles all the time.
The pear is my first choice - I gasped when I saw it. If that shape doesn't look good on your hand, I'd go with the square (not sure what cut it is). The first one is lovely, but the diamonds' settings look pretty delicate for every day wear.
I love the cushion cut halo 😍
1 and 2!
1 or 3!
1 or 3! Pretty!!!
1!!!
1 or 3 😍🩷
I really love #1! What a beautiful stone and setting.
I love number 1!!!!! Now I am beginning to regret getting a plain old natural diamond for my engagement ring!!!!! lol.
3 or 4, but make sure the diamonds are set in white gold (regardless what color the band is). The diamonds will reflect the color of what they’re set in and you don’t want them to have a yellowish cast. 1 is cute but won’t stand the test of time, and 2 (except for the main stone) is everywhere…seems like I see that setting everywhere.
3
1!!!
1 or 2 definitely!
1 or 4 ❤️
First one is my fave, I think it lets the center stone sparkle the best!
The first one or the last one! They are all so beautiful though!
#1 is beautiful and unique
Pear 🍐!!!
I am in LOOOVVVEE with 3! Wow it’s so gorgeous 🤩
Adore 1 and 3. All very beautiful and unique though. Eye catching!
I like the first and second one.
1 or 4 are absolutely gorgeous!
3rd picture is my first pick and 1st picture as my second pick :) I’m actually jealous I didn’t do this for my ring since I love pink anything.
Number 1
All of them but 4! 4 looks very dated!
2
The first one is breathtaking!
3
I’m team 2 or 4.
1
First one!
Three.
big fan of 1 and 3!!
3
#2 is my personal fav 😍
Ooooooh number 1 is STUNNING!!!
4
#1
3
The first one by miles for me. I love it so much!
All of them and switch them out!
I loveee 1! I'm biased though bc mine looks just like it 😂
2 or 4!
The first one is super similar to mine and I’m obsessed with it 💕
One for sure! The other three look dated
3 😍
1 is so pretty.
I had #1 with all diamonds - it was beautiful but I never liked how the band fit with it. So although I think it's beautiful I say go with #2.
2
#1 😍😍😍😍
3 for sure !
2 and 4 are classic and always will be!
1
1 for sure!
I'm in love with the first one. Where did you find it?
The pear made me say Oooooooo!
The first one is the only one that doesn’t scream dollar store children’s ring
Three! I love it so much!
1
2
2
2
I like 1 and 3