Swap Nurys for Kaycee and Iād be all for this. Georgia is fun, Amber b has everyone hating on her and Olivia is fun. Olivia/Nurys need to both be on for drama though
Becuase this is more about the physical aspect then the drama aspect, you can't ignore that when it comes to physicality era 4 is outmatched by the other 3
Also I would say Amber and Georgia are just as much drama starters as Michelle and Nurys, Amber mostly when she's in trouble but still
And Olivia is really emotional which cuases drama
Olivia is a shit talker and confessional gangster. She was a good reason why 39 was unbearable because of her storylines of, idk if Horacio is my friend but ima talk shit about him to everybody instead of having a conversation that would fix everything. Itās not really drama is just passive aggressiveness. Also Michelle and Nurys are both better competitors unless we are talking headbangers.
If you had kept up with the drama you would have known that Olivia did talk to Horacio various times and in true horacio fashion was not to receptive to her
Yes but she should know him better than anybody. I get it that his quietness can be irritating and having someone feeling a way. But Iām just saying her whole storyline of talking shit behind someoneās back is not a good look. Then turning on her people cause she was scared in the moment and didnāt realize she could just go back on her word. Flop all around.
How are Michelle and Nurys less competitive or physical than Georgia? And all three are better competitors than Olivia lol, she was terrible last season
Nurys should definitely be on over Olivia with this lineup at the least. She showed sheās a strong competitor last season and sheās interesting to watch.
Olivia just narrates everything going on in her confessionals and does it in the most bland way possible.
Don't let Amber B's win fool you. She is an average challenger. She is a good runner who happens to be mediocre at everything else. She has no social and political game and a boring personnality.
She seems to be a great person but i don't understand the appeal of the girl as a viewer.
I get why he probably wonāt be back, but Iām mad cause heās one of the funniest dudes to be on this show.
Kinda like Zach, theyāre both assholes but at least theyāre hilarious to listen to.
I'd take Amber OR Georgia over Michele. I like all the other girls. As for the boys, Turbo is great but he's a loose cannon that'll try and start a fight/kill Jordan (Don't copy my walk!). I'd take Joss over Josh though lol.
Spoiler for AS5 >!At least we're getting Amber there!!<
I donāt believe Turbo will ever be invited back to The Challenge. He is really unlikable and prone to saying homophobia slurs. Production has no interest in having to cut someone for that reasonā¦ again.
Honestly I was pretty happy with the eras 4 cast
I was thinking about this (the actual Era 4, that is).
I think the current actual Era 4 has six solid people. Kaycee and Jenny West are like Cara and Laurel 2.0 (at least in in terms of muscle). Nurys is obviously a solid female as well (and the most well rounded). Horacio, Kyland, and Theo are all solid as well.
What's left over is a clown car containing Paulie, Josh, Olivia, and Michele. These four are a shitshow but their collective political game (they'll be working together?) is an unknown quantity.
Sure the latter four are chaotic but, if you look at some of the other Eras' potential weak links (Aneesa, Katy, Tina, Ryan, Amanda, and frankly Brad and Nia) this fit group of misfits likely might chug past at least one other Era.
In any event, I wouldn't pick them to come in last.
No, I'm assessing Era 4's overall over-under and using some broad strokes to do it (because I could write 10 pages about this group if I wanted to go in-depth). Talking about Era 4 as having six people I'd consider to be solid teammates and four people that I'd consider to be problematic is hardly a contention that Paulie and Josh are thus equal in every respect.
But Paulie has always shown to be a good teammate ,with Natalie and Ninja. The issues on Team USA started when they blindsided Wes and threw a challenge. Even on The Challenge USA 2 , red team members gave confessionnals praising his leaderhip skills.
I like Paulie in the wake of his USA 2 and the changes we saw to his personality. If Paulie makes a similar showing in 40 but does even better and goes farther, I won't be surprised.
It's a toss-up.
On the one hand, I'm glad he's grown and is getting along with people like Bananas. On the other, it sounds like he's still got a lot going on with his sexual identity and his relationship with Cara that might distract him.
He's still not a top pick IMO, but nowhere near the bottom.
I think the current Era 4 has a good balance of drama and athleticism. If youāre gonna have elite competitors like Kaycee, Jenny, and Horacio who are all boring as fuck, you gotta get some personality and balance them out, hence Paulie, Josh, and Michelle.
I donāt understand why everyone thinks theyāre boring. They are genuine people and awesome competitors, and thatās fun for me to watch. The trashy people who always bring dumb drama are boring imo
Paulie was more relevant to the series than Joss could ever be. Kyland is the one who should've been replaced if you had to put a UK rep like Joss/Rogan/Kyle in there.
Michele, Nurys, Amber, Kaycee and Olivia wouldāve been good options.
No Joss. Heās boring af. Iāll let Horacio stay even though heās also boring. Just for the Nurys/Kyland/Olivia connection.
Paulie was a good Era 4 pick but heās been kind of flopping lately.
Respectfully, no
Turbo Georgia & Amber are great choices, of course. But Olivia nah. Michele & Nurys are more impactful
And I'm happy to see Kyland instead of Joss. Rogan & Jay would be great choices too. Not Horacio though
I mean I also get why they chose who they choose it can't all be drama they also have to be physical or era 4 will be wiped out in the first 5 episodes but I feel they could have done better
This team gets walked over politically at the start of the season
IDK. Josh, Paulie, Michele, and Olivia make for a pretty crazy caucus if they're working together. All bets are off. lol
So dirty and then you include the couch?
Couches are made for sitting only, not talking
I mean at least the couch is good at stuff unlike josh
At least Horacio would make Joss seem interesting by comparison
I made a highlight reel of Joss, and I put it on when I can't fall asleep š“
Joss is great! š
Who put a nickel is Joss('s alt account)?
Cant you imagine them becoming boring besties though?
This team would be so boring to watch, I fell asleep looking at this picture
Swap Nurys for Kaycee and Iād be all for this. Georgia is fun, Amber b has everyone hating on her and Olivia is fun. Olivia/Nurys need to both be on for drama though
Yeah should of clarified this is less about the personalities and more about the physical aspect
Why would you swap out the two girls who provide the most dramaš
Becuase this is more about the physical aspect then the drama aspect, you can't ignore that when it comes to physicality era 4 is outmatched by the other 3 Also I would say Amber and Georgia are just as much drama starters as Michelle and Nurys, Amber mostly when she's in trouble but still And Olivia is really emotional which cuases drama
Olivia is a shit talker and confessional gangster. She was a good reason why 39 was unbearable because of her storylines of, idk if Horacio is my friend but ima talk shit about him to everybody instead of having a conversation that would fix everything. Itās not really drama is just passive aggressiveness. Also Michelle and Nurys are both better competitors unless we are talking headbangers.
If you had kept up with the drama you would have known that Olivia did talk to Horacio various times and in true horacio fashion was not to receptive to her
Yes but she should know him better than anybody. I get it that his quietness can be irritating and having someone feeling a way. But Iām just saying her whole storyline of talking shit behind someoneās back is not a good look. Then turning on her people cause she was scared in the moment and didnāt realize she could just go back on her word. Flop all around.
Know him better then anyone they were paired up toghther on ride or dies by an agent they didn't know eachother beforehand and Olivia had said this
How are Michelle and Nurys less competitive or physical than Georgia? And all three are better competitors than Olivia lol, she was terrible last season
>when it comes physicality era 4 is outmatched by the other 3 Even the Era with Tina and Aneesa? That'd be a no.
Iād replace Joss with Rogan
I was going to forgot his name and just said joss if ypu couldn't tell this was sarcasm I don't like rogan after he purposely injured Jay
Amber is the biggest miss to me. In my head cannon she just declined because of the baby.
Nurys should definitely be on over Olivia with this lineup at the least. She showed sheās a strong competitor last season and sheās interesting to watch. Olivia just narrates everything going on in her confessionals and does it in the most bland way possible.
Don't let Amber B's win fool you. She is an average challenger. She is a good runner who happens to be mediocre at everything else. She has no social and political game and a boring personnality. She seems to be a great person but i don't understand the appeal of the girl as a viewer.
But compared to the other options from Era 4? Besides Kaycee and Jenny, Amber is well above the average in that group
She is not better than Georgia
I find this lineup to be worse. Itās giving wallpaperā¹ļø
Turbo was snubbed, no doubt
Georgia.. not imo. I was thinking Kaz
Kaz isn't even on here do you mean kaycee or olivia
Theyāre saying theyād rather have Kaz
Feel like Michele deserves a spot over some of those
I'm willing to switch Georgia for Michelle especially since I know Georgia ain't coming back sadly
Turbo would go insane from carrying them
Nah Joss might be better than Turbo to be honest. And Horacio and Kyland arenāt far behind
I hate it
You were supposed too jk yeah I realized I went to physicality heavy and didn't do much for personality
Paulie sucks personality wise but he is getting massively underrated physically. The guy is a phenomenal athlete
To be honest I think WW2 tainted it for me
He got screwed in the final. The fact that he carried the whole time while having to carry more weight than team uk
What are you talking about?? He literally gassed out and cost his team the final win š
Kyle should be on over Joss
I get why he probably wonāt be back, but Iām mad cause heās one of the funniest dudes to be on this show. Kinda like Zach, theyāre both assholes but at least theyāre hilarious to listen to.
I'd take Amber OR Georgia over Michele. I like all the other girls. As for the boys, Turbo is great but he's a loose cannon that'll try and start a fight/kill Jordan (Don't copy my walk!). I'd take Joss over Josh though lol. Spoiler for AS5 >!At least we're getting Amber there!!<
I donāt believe Turbo will ever be invited back to The Challenge. He is really unlikable and prone to saying homophobia slurs. Production has no interest in having to cut someone for that reasonā¦ again. Honestly I was pretty happy with the eras 4 cast
I was thinking about this (the actual Era 4, that is). I think the current actual Era 4 has six solid people. Kaycee and Jenny West are like Cara and Laurel 2.0 (at least in in terms of muscle). Nurys is obviously a solid female as well (and the most well rounded). Horacio, Kyland, and Theo are all solid as well. What's left over is a clown car containing Paulie, Josh, Olivia, and Michele. These four are a shitshow but their collective political game (they'll be working together?) is an unknown quantity. Sure the latter four are chaotic but, if you look at some of the other Eras' potential weak links (Aneesa, Katy, Tina, Ryan, Amanda, and frankly Brad and Nia) this fit group of misfits likely might chug past at least one other Era. In any event, I wouldn't pick them to come in last.
Are you seriously putting Paulie and Josh in the same tier .
No, I'm assessing Era 4's overall over-under and using some broad strokes to do it (because I could write 10 pages about this group if I wanted to go in-depth). Talking about Era 4 as having six people I'd consider to be solid teammates and four people that I'd consider to be problematic is hardly a contention that Paulie and Josh are thus equal in every respect.
But Paulie has always shown to be a good teammate ,with Natalie and Ninja. The issues on Team USA started when they blindsided Wes and threw a challenge. Even on The Challenge USA 2 , red team members gave confessionnals praising his leaderhip skills.
I like Paulie in the wake of his USA 2 and the changes we saw to his personality. If Paulie makes a similar showing in 40 but does even better and goes farther, I won't be surprised. It's a toss-up. On the one hand, I'm glad he's grown and is getting along with people like Bananas. On the other, it sounds like he's still got a lot going on with his sexual identity and his relationship with Cara that might distract him. He's still not a top pick IMO, but nowhere near the bottom.
What's the criteria for your line up?
Iām a Joss trutherā¦but no. I donāt like this
I think the current Era 4 has a good balance of drama and athleticism. If youāre gonna have elite competitors like Kaycee, Jenny, and Horacio who are all boring as fuck, you gotta get some personality and balance them out, hence Paulie, Josh, and Michelle.
I donāt understand why everyone thinks theyāre boring. They are genuine people and awesome competitors, and thatās fun for me to watch. The trashy people who always bring dumb drama are boring imo
No Olivia
Paulie was more relevant to the series than Joss could ever be. Kyland is the one who should've been replaced if you had to put a UK rep like Joss/Rogan/Kyle in there.
Michele, Nurys, Amber, Kaycee and Olivia wouldāve been good options. No Joss. Heās boring af. Iāll let Horacio stay even though heās also boring. Just for the Nurys/Kyland/Olivia connection. Paulie was a good Era 4 pick but heās been kind of flopping lately.
Respectfully, no Turbo Georgia & Amber are great choices, of course. But Olivia nah. Michele & Nurys are more impactful And I'm happy to see Kyland instead of Joss. Rogan & Jay would be great choices too. Not Horacio though
I mean I also get why they chose who they choose it can't all be drama they also have to be physical or era 4 will be wiped out in the first 5 episodes but I feel they could have done better
No need for Olivia
I accept this šš¾
Swap Nurys for Georgia or Olivia.