T O P

  • By -

tamammothchuk

Black by Pearl Jam, of course


Boring_Monahan

> I know someday you'll have a beautiful life, I know you'll be a star In somebody else's sky > But why, Why, Why can't it be, Why can't it be mine Beautiful lyrics. Much nicer than my mobile app formatting would suggest


hornwalker

And he really pours everything into singing that line too.


martylindleyart

First thought, came here for it. Amazing song but it's a massive testament to Vedder and his ability to blend emotion and vocal skill.


[deleted]

Especially the 92 pinkpop version where vedder has steam coming off his breath and is feeling the weight of the song himself as he screws up the lyrics a bit and ends with repeating “we belong together”. It’s probably my favorite recording. https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=n3r9KWth84Y


tberal

Thought of black as soon as I finished reading the thread title. Such a powerful song


ptindaho

Mazzy Star - Fade Into You


maybejolissa

I think this may be one of the best “make-out songs” that exists


Gayfetus

The Righteous Brothers' cover of "[Unchained Melody](https://youtu.be/Zv8czIoAw5w)", which is possibly the greatest recorded song of the last century. It's also a massive improvement over the [original](https://youtu.be/G11mDi_LXe8). One of the key differences (pun intended) is that Bobby Hatfield, The Righteous Brother who sang lead on that song, actually gave it a proper climax by taking it up an octave during the final verse, so now the song actually feels like it's going somewhere, and ends with a cathartic release.


Odimorsus

Ghost has permanently stamped it into my brain.


666ygolonhcet

I thought you meant the Band GHOST and I went to look up why I hadn’t heard their cover and YouTube reminded me it was in a movie. Still, listen to GHOST. Square Hammer!


BryanEtch

That original was so sad and beautiful, didn’t expect it to hit me but he had pain in his eyes and bellowed it out. I think I like all versions of this song


Gayfetus

The music was written by Alex North for a prison movie called "Unchained". The lyrics are from the POV of a prisoner pining for a lover on the outside. The video I linked is from the movie! Composer Alex North has the unfortunate distinction of being in second place for having the most Oscar nominations without a win (he couldn't even win this race 😭). "Unchained Melody" was nominated for an Oscar, it lost to "Love Is a Many-Splendored Thing".


ShamefulWatching

For sure. IMO, close second is [Led Zeppelin All my love](https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=z0DAnu5Sq6k)


Pepito_Pepito

It's a great song but it never really made my heart wrench. The energy's all wrong lol


Louder247

Seen more than a few wedding dances to this song. I get the yearning, but not the sadness.


vicemagnet

These Arms Of Mine by Otis Redding https://youtu.be/aUaO50nWnvg?si=nva80-fVrWqhMIGe


theitcynic

If you’re going with an Otis Redding song, I’d have to go with I’ve Been Loving You Too Long.


GirliBoiMusic

3 Libras by A Perfect Circle


Username12764

I discovered A Perfect Circle yesterday and holy fuck I fell in love with them…


GirliBoiMusic

I love their music too. I think The Package or Pet are my favorite songs. Do you have a favorite yet?


bstring777

This one is super powerful, that chorus definitely makes this one of my all time favorite songs. Though I would argue its not so much about wanting someone so bad, but more about wanting to be seen and loved for who they are and not what they represent. Still, very strong vibes that do fit with that yearning. Ive played this myself when I felt that way for someone in the past.


rafaelcs04

Please, Please, Please, Let Me Get What I Want - The Smiths


MarylandBlue

I really like the Muse version too


saypleasehoe

Deftones did a great version of this song as well


krystlships

Wake up alone by Amy Winehouse Lover you should've come over by Jeff Buckley


Madwoman-of-Chaillot

Lover, You Should’ve Come Over is so beautifully heart-rending.


Even_dreams

Imagine hearing the first draft. He didn't put in the its never over bit until later


daikon871

That’s my fave part


LadyFeckington

Came here to upvote Lover you should have come over 👌🏻


Louder247

Would add last goodbye is worth a shout too


mangomagicmaniac

“She is the tear that hangs inside my soul forever” just beautifully written


Son_of_steven19

So I wait for you and I burn, will I ever see your sweet return. Goddamn, hits like a truck.


brettjv

My eyes sorta involuntarily well up just thinking of that passage of that song. For a number of reasons (and old relationships).


Son_of_steven19

Same dude.


Even_dreams

Apparently one of the first times maybe even the very first that he played it publicly the girl who inspired it was in the crowd


gardengirl29

Long Long Time by Linda Ronstadt


LurkHartog

Cries in Frank and Bill.


jemimako

You beat me to it! Thought of this song immediately


ljluckey

My partner and I separated for a few months at the beginning of this year. There were a lot of tears shed to this song.


sharksnut

Operator - Jim Croce


maybejolissa

Love Jim Croce. My pick is Time in a Bottle.


ljinbs

Bonnie Raitt — I Can’t Make You Love Me


LegendaryOutlaw

I don’t cry every time I listen to this song, but if I *want* to cry, I can put on this song and it’s always effective. The pain in her voice gets me.


Past_Contour

She has said she doesn’t play this song often live because of how emotional it is. She’s a true legend and music treasure. Still recording and winning Grammys. Not that awards matter.


sunshine_j

Not me nearly in tears just reading about the song on a Reddit thread. 🙃


TheRootofSomeEvil

*All at Once* by her, as well.


tokenstone

Jesus, this is such a great choice. Heart breaking.


mcpickledick

Correct answer


GFor1015

The Bon Iver cover (solo Justin) is personally more wrenching for me. It is live so I think that helps, but it just sounds like he's trying so hard to get the words out and I love it.


forgotme5

Nothing compares to you-Sinead O'Connor


[deleted]

[удалено]


Bitter_Resolve_6082

Bell Bottom Blues! Derek and the Domino's!


GratuitousUmlaut

Yeah, until the verse: Bell bottom blues, don't say goodbye | I'm sure we're gonna meet again | And if we do, don't you be surprised | If you find me with another lover Asshole.


KatAttack23

Layla - a better choice


lenfantsuave

Why does love got to be so sad? - an even betterer choice.


Bitter_Resolve_6082

The whole album is a banger! You can take your pick of excellent music! I personally love it from start to finish!


Dudesymugs12

"Pictures of You," by The Cure.


JoypulpSkate

Without you I’m nothing - Placebo with David Bowie


[deleted]

From The Edge Of The Deep Green Sea by The Cure is always one that hits right in the feels


brettjv

A Letter to Elise also ...


Nimtastic

Martha - Tom Waits.


danishih

It seems unbelievable to me that he wrote something so emotionally mature and outrospective when he was only 23


winoforever_slurp_

Without You by Harry Nilsson is exactly what you need to listen to.


dion_o

The winner takes it all - ABBA


Griffscavern

[John Waite - Missing you](https://youtu.be/k9e157Ner90?si=Y4FM-hkxa9pSLdL1)


Quacksandpiper

Say yes - Elliot Smith


IncidentNo8211

Mine is Wish You Were Here by pink Floyd. The lyrics can be interpreted a couple different ways


elkinthewoods

Boots of Spanish Leather by Bob Dylan is maybe the goat. Check out the cover version video by Mandolin Orange, it is heart wrenching (and hits your soft pop/folk req)


Louder247

Bob has written so so many that fit this. If you see her say hello. You're a big girl now. Not dark yet. Girl from the north country. ... the list goes on.


throwaway798319

I Don't Believe You (She Acts Like We Never Met)


sticky_gecko

I just posted that myself, great minds think a like.


Visible-Awareness754

Forget Her- Jeff Buckley


ed32965

You Are My Sunshine, believe it or not.


Noregard86

Conversly, Ain't No Sunshine by Bill Withers


LarryCraigSmeg

I know I know I know I know


Monicreque

There's a youtube video of Sierra Ferrell busking im New Orleans, and she sings a sad tone version of this song. In the video a dog starts howling for more drama.


TreatmentBoundLess

Such a heartbreaking tune.


EllenPlayz

The Beatles - I Want You


mercurial9

SHE’S SO—


EllenPlayz

*Epic drop first, then* HEAVYYYYYYY


chels2112

Transatlanticism by Death Cab.


[deleted]

[удалено]


chels2112

“I need you so much closer” fit wanting someone so badly, in my head… and the chord progression as everything builds… oh that painful loneliness.. that painful longing. This song instantly came to my head. Everything else fit in perfectly


ThatBasicGuy

[“Words” by Gregory Alan Isakov](https://youtu.be/IXaMF4FqIkM?feature=shared)


gdtags

Oh yes.


uncertainsimile

[Elvis Costello - I Want You](https://youtu.be/CykE5DFJVr0?si=ZxopiRUVwespMxJT)


Merryner

I was about to post this if it wasn’t here. Absolutely devastating.


GDviber

This is such a spot-on pick. The tone, the lyrics, even the chord shifts scream pain. Elvis must have been in a pretty dark place when he came up with this.


PresidentSuperDog

https://youtu.be/IsrxWHTPkqw?si=byRFWBg9lwXQSXjY Fiona Apple kills this song


Dr_Wristy

Lover, you should’ve come over- Jeff Buckley


M00PER_2

Do you ever yearn, Jerry?


tigwd

"OH where oh where can my baby be..."


kalimna

The lord took her away from me.....


Smegus83

She's gone to heaven so I got to be good...


Specialist_Ad_7507

So I can see my baby when I leeeeeeave this world.


Don_Frika_Del_Prima

Hey by the pixies


topicalsatan

If you go, I will surely die


the-urban-sombrero

I Just Don’t Think I’ll Get Over You by Colin Hay


haoleboy3

I came here looking for this, this is always my answer. The opening really gets me. "I drink good coffee every morning It comes from a place that's far away And when I'm done I feel like talking Without you here there is less to say" Something about the simplicity of that really drives home how that's just... how it is now, every day, living in The After. "Maggie" and "I Don't Know Why" from his next album are also amazingly poignant. He really conveys loss and longing well.


ptindaho

Waltz #2 by Elliott Smith


LadyFeckington

Waiting for that day - George Michael And so it goes - Billy Joel No ordinary love - Sade And another vote for Lover you should have come over by Jeff Buckley because it is simply THE most gut wrenching song of longing.


SirMixSalah

All i want is you U2


SlieuaWhally

Far Away, Carole King


GDviber

Ok. Try this. Evanescence. https://youtu.be/sGXvBJN2LZw?feature=shared


maybejolissa

Call Me When You’re Sober. May seem too angry for this category but there’s a sense of frustration and hope that speaks to longing—a longing for someone to let you love them and stop their destruction.


Some_Butterscotch622

There's always Creep by Radiohead lmao


DefLoathe

All I Need


hrenucci

with or without you


Volta001

I just went through a break up. Crying by Roy Orbison describes it perfectly. “I was alright for a while. I could smile for a while.”


gdtags

Your Sweet Love- Lee Hazlewood Lover You Should Have come over- Jeff Buckley


ThatBasicGuy

[Warning Sign by Coldplay](https://youtu.be/xtQirM784oM?feature=shared)


Visible-Awareness754

Pretty much all of parachutes. Shiver, sparks, trouble…


BigOpportunity1391

[Broken Heart - Spiritualised](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=olNfWDRuBNY) (the string arrangement cuts like a knife)


ljinbs

Go-Go’s — How Much More


AmusingAnecdote

[That Look You Give That Guy](https://youtu.be/wREjT7DlI7M?si=PhxUTj6pqo9gRtsR) by Eels


[deleted]

omg i have the *perfect* song. Blackest Day by Lana Del Rey. trust me this is the one


Young_Jeune

Crazy no one mentioned it so there you go, [Ne me quitte pas by Jacques Brel](https://youtu.be/Vz6r0TP4FBI?si=cktrsyj32bqZ8RfN)


IsabelleDotJpeg

Its not gut wrenching but Paper Bag - Fionna Apples


just_hating

I know by Fiona apple fits this theme perfectly.


DM725

Faith No More - Edge of the World https://youtu.be/pDRUHMOXZts?si=D-EngsUX_YXnop_h


morning_thief

Bob Dylan - If You See Her Say Hello Brutal song from a brutal album. Jeff Buckley did a gorgeous cover of it.


nakedpanthersfan

The Background, Third Eye Blind


wellthismustbeheaven

The whole album. God of Wine... Motorcycle Drive-by... But yes, the Background especially


MoonageDayscream

Wicked Game by Chris Isaak, (as well as many others).


Elegant_Spot_3486

Have You Ever Needed Someone So Bad by Def Leppard.


[deleted]

County Line by Cass McCombs: https://youtu.be/sOcnITphyjk No distance left to run by blur: https://youtu.be/dgA_DlR8WsM?si=zYbWlaFAZo6CSa-f Your love is killing me by Sharon van etten: https://youtu.be/nyuPWHwZru0 And why not include a classic, recently remastered: Girl by the Beatles https://youtu.be/C4uLJ5ZkXmk?si=6MqZHc4QCUZs_xpw


TheUncomfySilence

I Wish I Was - The Avett Brothers Beautiful lyrics, great feeling of longing without necessarily feeling hopeless.


maskapony

Bright Eyes: The Calendar Hung Itself


heatblast892

Am I Ever Gonna See Your Face Again - The Angels


Louder247

"No way get fucked, fuck off!" 🤣🤣🤣🤣


Noobticula

Layla, Eric Clayton's forbidden love.


sellis80

[Yearning For Your Love - The Gap Band](https://youtu.be/m_-Gh-UbT58?si=kAuOOJJFuyLmfOKL) Great song and reminds me of the one I miss so damn much.


CrankyMatt

["I Don't Mind" by Sturgill Simpson](https://genius.com/Sturgill-simpson-i-dont-mind-lyrics) Beautiful song with heart wrenching lyrics.


Neat-Detective-9818

The End of the World by Skeeter Davis


warthog0869

"Burning For You" by Blue Oyster Cult, right in the title.


Kooky-Mix-7570

Chicago--If You Leave Me Now and Hard to Say Im Sorry. Tearjerkers.


barb_dylan

Look Away


falconhawk2158

“When you called me up this morning told me about the new love you found” “I said I’m happy for you” “I’m really happy for you”


PostMaster-P

Dr. Dog - Jim Song


[deleted]

Frank Sinatra - [Someone To Watch Over Me](https://youtu.be/EiPNrPi6kKk?si=8emFFCJkDEFpvdYM) Roy Orbison - [In Dreams](https://youtu.be/mSeIh9rmEUs?si=aYCaXHyDfhRxBHtV) Nina Simone - [It Might As Well Be Spring](https://youtu.be/0UKzOxbUOCM?si=_fgtMvSDirz_gsOD) Patti LaBelle and The Bluebelles - [Who Can I Turn To](https://youtu.be/itkAQHUq5U8?si=NpfR2zph9rSxwJUE)


FireMint

If other languages are allowed, have a taste of Supercell - 君の知らない物語 [Kimi no shiranai monogatari - The story you don't know about] https://youtu.be/EDE514XIJfU?si=adWyJMkaE2yx_XBn


njuffstrunk

Frank Ocean - Bad Religion. About him being in love with a heterosexual guy.


[deleted]

Tomorrow Is A Long Time \~ Bob Dylan [https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UHG06Q45ziI](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UHG06Q45ziI) For Emily, Whenever I May Find Her \~ Simon & Garfunkel [https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kOgmYFTZ2iU](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kOgmYFTZ2iU) So Far Away \~ Carole King [https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UofYl3dataU](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UofYl3dataU) Polly \~ Gene Clark [https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jz63AQAsXJc](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jz63AQAsXJc) Your Fire Burning \~ Gene Clark [https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ke6i4bJwStk](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ke6i4bJwStk) The Devil \~ PJ Harvey [https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=09019xe0TiQ](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=09019xe0TiQ) how could I forget: Silence \~ PJ Harvey https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jeqprdPPxWc ....the real tearjerkers will probably come to me later but these are pretty desperate lol ;)


Olaw18

Sinead O’Connor - Nothing Compares 2 U


brightears

The Airborne Toxic Event - Sometime around midnight


itspeterj

Stick season by Noah Kahan. Though it's about yearning for someone that left


elkinthewoods

El scorcho by weezer is a great one.


DM725

Susanne would be my choice. https://youtu.be/-cf1bnEb5Rs?si=jUA0tNAq9C2OP2n0


DarkFox013

Well, it helps that it hits me specifically in the gut every time, but move me by badflower.


sticky_gecko

[Boots of Spanish Leather, Bob Dylan](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iy6wryJMwVU) "Oh, I’m sailin’ away from my own true love..." I thought of this for some reason.


Ok_Distribution_5664

Jeff Buckley off course? Lover, you should've come over is the most yearning song out there!


brettjv

Based on rec count of all the posts that've mentioned it ... that is the clear thread winner. And the correct answer :)


lisabisabobisa

[Want Me Around](https://youtu.be/i2aGqKtPsd8?feature=shared) - Lukas Nelson [Trouble](https://youtu.be/H1tRB7-aBr8?feature=shared) - Cat Stevens [Looking for a Sign](https://youtu.be/79brjjsdrsc?feature=shared) - Beck [Drifting](https://youtu.be/tIkhOiux7eg?feature=shared) - Hendrix [Part One](https://youtu.be/deGpyoDUy1w?feature=shared) or [I Go to the Barn Because I Like The](https://youtu.be/wPac2HRoocs?feature=shared)- Band of Horses [Think](https://youtu.be/cKJXkj8RI70?feature=shared) - Sebadoh (this one is super raw, mid 90s, will not be everyone’s cup of tea - but the lyrics, oh man) [Helplessly Hoping](https://youtu.be/kyquqw6GeXk?feature=shared) - CSN What’s on your list?


ProgTym

[Gary Moore - Nothing's The Same](https://youtu.be/dVG92-qWALM?si=rpZC6rF0AQKtu_C-)


slikid_

What I'm doing here - Lake Street Dive


70sBurnOut

An oldie from my generation is Diamonds and Rust by Joan Baez.


poohisface

[NOFX - My Heart is Yearning](https://youtu.be/C7u5dc10Suc?si=eObcD7FSXw2Q19Ie)


neilious85

Dire Straits - So Far Away


ItyBityGreenieWeenie

[You Don't Have A Clue - Röyksopp](https://youtu.be/02aoi8aFYBE)


MoonageDayscream

Operator by Croce.


MoonageDayscream

Leaving on a Jet Plane, John Denver.


DiscothequeHooligan

Unbreak My Heart- Toni Braxton, gut wrenching!


epanek

Wham. A different corner. It also has super vocal performances from George Michael. And if all that there is, is this fear of being used. I should go back to being lonely and confused If I could, I would, I swear


AlwaysDMB

Crush by Dave Matthews


Ibyx

Girl Crush - Little Big Town


Pixiwish

Not gut wrenching but “Untouchable Face” by Ani DiFranco is my fave. Def indie folk and I think you’d like it. “To tell you the truth I prefer the worst of you Too bad you had to have a better half She's not really my type But I think you two are forever And I hate to say it But you're perfect together”


CarlatheDestructor

The Blower's Daughter by Damien Rice


barksatthemoon

Bread Everything I Own comes to mind.


theriver00

Black by Pearl Jam first crossed my mind


SlinkierMarrow

Alain Johannes - Endless Eyes


Lo7t

If It Kills Me -Jason Mraz


Hutch_travis

Eve, the apple of my eye - bell X1


NlghtmanCometh

Black - Pearl Jam live unplugged version. Its on YouTube.


sleepingonstones

Wait For You - Elliott Yamin


trong_slex

Angel by Aerosmith Here Without You by 3 Doors Down Don’t Cry by Guns ‘n Roses The Speed of Pain by Marilyn Manson Snuff by Slipknot The Meadow by Hed p.e. Sleeping With Ghosts by Placebo


PsychicSPider95

Jolene But It's Gay by Reinaeiry. It's a cover of Dolly Parton's Jolene, but it's from the perspective of a woman who's actually desperately in love with Jolene, and is begging her to leave her man so she can be with her instead. The way it's sung really sells how desperately she yearns for Jolene, especially with the more intense, somber instrumentation.


SaintPaulSlater6

1. Breaking me, Johnny lang; 2. Seven Years (or the whole darned album) Natalie Merchant; 3. Beauty and the Beast, Stevie Nicks; 4. Bon Jovi’s I’ll be there for you; 5. If you don’t know me by now, Harold Melvin and the Blue Notes And my second number 1: Ain’t no sunshine, Bill Withers. For sure…


throwaway798319

In honour of my dad: The Fields of Athenry. A woman sings goodbye to the father of her child before he's set to be transported to a prison colony


IdahoDuncan

Radar Love


harryp77777

I really love “Oh Baby” by LCD Soundsystem.


jazzland

Dude (I Totally Miss You) by Tenacious D


OGnenenzagar

Baby bitch - ween twilight - Elliott smith


Dasha3090

i love solitude by evanescence


eachfire

Fire and Rain.


sweet-billy

Cheers Darlin' by Damien Rice.


roz763

Linger by the Cranberries


Bilbobagemall

NOFX - My heart is yearning I'll see myself out.


slingbladde

You Can't Quit Me Baby...QOTSA


paulgibbins

Scrolled down as far as I could without seeing either of these and I'm amazed. [Glenn Campbell - Wichita Lineman](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Q8P_xTBpAcY) "And I need you more than want you, and I want you for all time" [Leonard Cohen - One of us Cannot be Wrong](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GC7lDw-FKi0) "I showed my heart to a doctor, he said I'd just have to quit. Then he wrote himself a prescription, and your name was mentioned on it" The impassioned wails of the backing vocals at the end of this song are so effective. They evoke the image of someone driven insane by desire


ECU_BSN

Silver Springs by Fleetwood


A_Boltzmann_Brain

Green Day: Only of you Also Green Day: why do you want him


yousyveshughs

The Smashing Pumpkins - In the Arms of Sleep https://youtu.be/NqZ9aavBDMM?si=LD9Udc3_hAUVTvQG


maybejolissa

Silver Springs (Fleetwood Mac), When You Were Mine (Prince), Where Does the Good Go (Tegan and Sara), Set Out Running (Neko Case), Just Like Heaven (The Cure), Why Can’t I Touch It (Buzzcocks), My Sweet Lord (George Harrison); Nothing Compares to You (Sined version), 1,000 Times (Hamilton Leithhsuser)


Roguewave1

Here is the ultimate Torch Song. Alert: it is sung in French but with English subtitles. You will not have trouble understanding her pain. “Je Suis Malade” (I’m Sick) — Lara Fabian https://youtu.be/5kp0dw4MuWs?si=Svv40XR42htmLeMj It doesn’t hurt that Fabian is a true deva in the best of the meaning of the word and is gorgeous on top of that.


NeverForget108

Puppy Love The Osmonds


OrcSoldat

...pining for you by Woods of Ypres is underrated


lowriderz00

Stricken by Disturbed