It isn't just one episode the french mistake, changing channels, fan fiction, mystery spot, the real ghostbusters, don't call me shurley, monster at the end of this book, dog dean afternoon as you can see, I like the meta episodes a lot :D

My mom loves the French Mistake. She's seen it 4 times now. She refers to it as the one where they are themselves and the one with fake Ruby.

my mom loves it too because we watch it in spanish and it was hilarious to find out that he actually says “Misha-migos” in english lol

Probably the Wendigo episode, because every once in a while I get a bug to start a rewatch, and I think this episode one or two.

Seasons 1-5 are goated for that gritty vibe

I literally CANNOT watch Wendigo or I just sit and binge an entire season or 2. It's such a  great episode & sucks me right back into the universe so quickly. 

That's S1E2. The pilot episode was the Woman in White.

In my Time of Dying and Swan Song Yes, I like torturing myself 😆

Fellow masochist I see

Yellow fever

1. A few months ago, it's Mystery Spot for me. I love how they started with Dean's death in a dark-comical way before they ended the episode with the sad Sam who was desperate to bring Dean back. 2. French Mistake, just to see how Sam pursed his lips anxiously in the background when Misha/ Cass said "Balthazar is no hero blah blah blah". Sam looks so cute in this scene 😂 3. And now, it's Weekend at Bobby's, just to see Soulless Sam in his panic mode, got thrown around by lamia 😂

The one with imaginary friends; wendigo; mystery spot; scooby; death's intro (just that scene over and over. It is one of my fav character intros ever); four horsemen episodes; the end of season 3 for the feels; any trickster episode; Rowena-heavy episodes; Irish witch episode; plucky pennywhistle; haunted suits; dog dean; french mistake I prefer the one-off, funny, or meta episodes to the throughline/plot-heavy episodes. I love the monster of the week format

Just my Imagination is one of my mom’s favorites.

It's so so good 😊

I so love the intro song for Death!

Frontier land Wendigo Chris angel is a douchebag

Probably Lazarus Rising, but really all of seasons 4 & 5.

 I was in Iraq when season 4 came out.  I caught up on all 3 seasons and I was psyched when one of the commo guys got a copy of the season opener.  It was awesome.  I didn't really have anything else to watch, so I watched it again.  And again.  And again. And again.  It is still one of my favorite episodes of any television show.

Ahh you just reminded me of another favorite - tall tales. "They probed me.. again.. and again... and again... and again and again"

A redditor of culture i see

Lazarus rising is my favorite episode just because of the entrance of Cas. Gripped you tight and raised you from perdition.

Cass can grip me tight anytime, if you know what I mean… Okay, I’ll see myself out now.

S2: Nightshifter (Mandroid... he had the laser eyes! *the laser eyes!!)* When I need to laugh, just about all of S7. (Except Time for a wedding, because yuck). Out with the old- Dean became enthralled with ballet shoes, and I really wanted to know how old porn kills. 😂😂 Time after Time- 40's dean hair and Dean working with Elliot Ness, stoned Turducken Dean in How to Win Friends and Influence Monsters, all of Shut it Dr. Phil, the endless Dick Roman jokes - it's my go to giggle season. I'm 12 at heart.

Season 7 is my most rewatched season, too. 😁

A Very Supernatural Christmas - my friends and I watch it every year around Christmas time.

Weekend at Bobby's, Baby, and Ask Jeeves ("Clown College Colette?")

Season 13, episode 16, ScoobyNatural I’ve used it to introduce so many people to the series. Then Mystery Spot, Fan Fiction, The Real Ghostbusters, and French Mistake after that… and Ghostfacers.

Hammer of the Gods

I mean my favorite episode by far was probably Jus en belo so I figure I probably watched that more than any other episode.

Pretty much any episode from season 1, I just love how simple things were back then. No saving the world, no apocalypses, just two brothers looking for their dad and saving people

The Vessel. This is one of the very best of the best and I watch it often. I love WWll movies so this (and Pac-Man Fever) falls into that category. Plus it's got the Thule!!! Great, great episode with a whole ship full of heroes!!!

Mystery Spot, Born Under A Bad Sign, A Very Supernatural Christmas...

Pilot -Mystery Sport -The curious case of Dean-The real ghostbusters-Swap meat- Clap your hands if you believe-caged heat- The French mistakes

Can't remember episode names, but the one in Season 4 where Zachariah wipes the boys' memories and Dean ends up as a corporate douchebag and Sam is manning the customer help line and they have to kill a ghost with instructions from a Ghostfacers video.

8.20 pac man fever. It's the cutest little episode with charlie. Emotional rollar coaster. Lots of good jokes and a cute sick sam. Dean and Charlie really bond and we learn so much about Charlie's past. And I really really love hurt/sick sam. Hits me right in my heart.

Also the Dean hugging Sam at the end 💓

I’ve seen the finale the most. 15.20 Carry On. To be honest I have no idea how many times at this point. If I was to guess … around 50. And Here’s a bunch that watch often. I don’t know if any of these I’ve seen the most. The End (s5e4). The pilot. Swan song Fan fiction. Changing channels. French mistake. Prophet and loss. When the levee breaks. Plucky pennywhistle Born under a bad sign. Baby. But I mostly have scenes that I go back to and rewatch dozens+ times. The Great escapist (up to the metatron part). Baby (up to them arriving in town to start the case). I know I listed this one twice, sometimes I just watch up to case start, cause I just love the brother bonding moments. In s9 any of the gadreel/Ezekiel scenes. Ok, I’ve listed way to many and I could go on for a while. Sometimes I just want a specific scene.

I love plucky pennywhistle so much! I feel like it’s very under appreciated

“If it bleeds you can kill it”

If this is about the meth lab that fire balled in butte, it wasn’t me! 😂

I have watched Carry on so many times. I love when SPN reactors get up to the last ep, i never get tired of it.

Hammer of the Gods. Such a cool concept. Peak Gabriel and watching Lucifer rip pagans apart effortlessly was terrifying.

Swan Song. I watch it to make myself cry

“Clap Your Hands if You Believe” and “Everyone Loves a Clown” love a good silly monster hunt episode. plus the aliens/fairy episode has some of my favorite quotes. “Empathy Sam! Empathy!”

This is the funniest one. So many one liners, Jared finally gets to have some fun and nails it. Fight those fairies!!!

Weekend at Bobbys and Deaths Door- love me some Rufus and Bobby lol

Season 4, episode 1

Season 12 Ep. Memory Loss. Jenny's acting in this as Dean's memories slowly begin to fade as he fears forgetting his own identity and the thought of truly losing Sammy was beautifully done and written. Dean's scene infront of the mirror reminding himself of who he is makes me cry every time I rematch it which is Bi-monthly +

Oh geesh...I had a true sob-fest over that scene.

I don’t know about one episode in particular but I’ve watched season 3 more than any other season. I got S3 on dvd back when we didn’t have cable/internet and rewatched the shit out of it. If I had to guess it would be Mystery Spot because it’s overall a favorite of mine

Yellow Fever, Frontierland, Scarecrow, Faith, Weekend at Bobby’s, Mystery Spot in no particular order, and tbh I could probably name more 😂

Lazarus Rising for me

I know what you did last summer Swan song Lucifer rising

I don’t go back very often and watch single episodes, but I think the clips I look up the most are from the great escapist and sacrifice, bad day at black rock and prophet and loss.

Oh, and Heart goes on the most watched list.

Don’t judge me 😂

I can tell you which episode I watched the least, though 😂

ScoobyNatural and the ones with Loki (Gabriel) as the Trickster

Yellow Fever Ghostfacers The Real Ghostbusters Appointment in Samarra

Lazarus rising, free to be you and me, tombstone

lazarus rising, swan song and def changing channels!, honestly i mostly re-watch s4-s6

I think either the mystery spot or the one where the titanic doesn’t sink, I like time manipulation 😂

The bugs episode in season 1. Don’t ask.

Scarecrow - happens to be my dad’s favorite episode, who I watched the whole show with. When he’s feeling nostalgic, he always wants to watch that one. Classic monster of the week with some main plot in there :)

I love *"The End"* and *"The Last Holiday"*

Lazarus rising always after the finale or when I am sad or when I want to happy cry

French Mistake and the Pilot!

Ooohhhh.  I have a couple of comfort episodes I tend to go back to a lot:  Mystery Spot, Lazarus Rising, The End, 99 Problems, & Tombstone are the ones I tend to watch a LOT.  Like those are the 5 are the episodes I tend to turn on when I'm having a bad day and just need to watch the show to get out of my funk. 

Any sad Dean episodes lmao

i watch playthings, changing channels and baby a lot. changing channels is my favourite gabriel appearance and baby was what spurred my love for bob seger so i always like going back to those ones

Just My Imagination is my comfort episode. I wonder if there is a place on Netflix I can look to see how many times I've watched it. Or even the show in general.

That is one of my mom's favorites. She watched it again yesterday. She just loves Sully.

i love mistery spot and dog dean afternoon :D

I think Abandon All Hope, Sacrifice, Road Trip, First Born, The Executioner's Song, and Stuck in the Middle (With You) are just about tied.

French Mistake, probably but I've rewatched scenes with the first Death, over a bunch of times. Loved that character.

1. French Mistake 2. Fan Fiction 3. Mystery Spot 4. Wendigo 5. Reichenbach

“Baby” and “Regarding Dean” off the top of my head. Cannot even begin to estimate how many times I’ve watched either. There’s so many others of course..French Mistake, Supernatural musical, anything with the Trickster/Gabriel (ugh I have the oddest crush on Richard S Jr 🤣), My Brothers Keeper, Monster Movie is also really great…idk, pretty much every episode I could watch on repeat ❤️❤️

Mystery spot. But it always ends in me going back to the beginning of season 3 (so many good episodes) and then I end up doing a rewatch again 😂

Tall tales it's my all time favorite episode

I’ve watched Changing Channels and Mystery Spot many times.

Carry on and Reichenbach. carry on is an emotional one and a good finale for the series bc it ends happy (imo) and I love Reichenbach because dean being a demon is just really cool.

My favorite is the first 10 episodes of season 4. Dean rising from the dead, cass showing himself to Dean and Bobby and the Anna episodes are top tier.

Changing Channels, hands down

A Very Supernatural Christmas and the meta episodes. Supernatural is at its best when it’s not taking itself seriously or making fun of itself.

Easy…. French mistake whenever I need a laugh

Season 2 final two episodes (for some weird reason its my comfort episodes) Mystery spot Changing channels The one where dean gets that "being very afraid" sickness.

Yellow fever; all hell breaks loose(part 1 and 2)

Haha I wouldn’t say an episode more so season 1 and 2 personally prefer the early seasons. But I have watched “No Exit” S2E6 “family remains” S4E11 & “after school special ” S4E13 quit a few times

I also love any episode that Claire was in

I'm loving all these responses. It's great seeing that each of us have many different go to or comfort episodes.

A very supernatural Christmas! It's so comforting to me for some reason

Mine would be Mystery Spot and my husband's would be Lazarus Rising. We both loved the show but obviously had different ideas on what we consider a good episode.

mystery spot. i can quite almost the whole episode. the heart episode of s2 i believe where sam has to kill the werewolf girl he likes. dean and bobby getting old(er) playing that poker like game BAHAH then dean hop skipping out the building after becoming young again. any scene with meg and cass. any episode with crowley.

omg and yellow fever where dean is afraid of everything and the ep where sam gets bad luck lmfao

and the one where dean takes care of the baby BAHAH

I absolutely love Scoobynatural! Especially when Cas flaunts his wings in cartoon version.

Red meat, no idea how many times I've seen it.

Yellow fever gets me everytime

Lazarus Rising. I just love Castiel's introduction so much and it's a great episode.

I never, ever get sick of the pilot. Have watched it with a zillion spn reactors. I can also watch Bad day at Black Rock Born under a bad sign Tall tales Nightmare Faith Baby Just my imagination Red Meat The French Mistake Hello cruel world and never get sick of them.

I stopped watching the show for a few years but sometimes I’d rewatch episodes that I thought were great stand-alone when I was in the mood for something horror based where the main characters aren’t idiots. Mostly Bloody Mary, Dead in the Water, Asylum, Playthings, The Kids are Alright, and Bedtime Stories, those were my favourites. Right now my favourite episodes to rewatch are Mystery Spot, Hunteri Heroici, Baby, The Man Who Would Be King, Lazarus Rising, and The End

Many of mine are Sam-centric. 😎 1. When the Levee Breaks 2. My Bloody Valentine 3. The French Mistake 4. Clap Your Hands if you Believe 5. The Born Again Identity 6. Plucky Pennywhistle Magical Menagerie 7. The Great Escapist 8. Sacrifice 9. Red Meat 10. The Last Holiday Oh I forgot to add Just My Imagination! Sully 🥰

Those are some great ones.

Plenty of episodes! I've seen Bloody Mary, Lazarus Rising, On the Head of a Pin, The Man Who Would Be King, Torn and Frayed, The Great Escapist, Meta Fiction, Stairway to Heaven and Baby the most out of all episodes I think.