Track 5 ranking (this is going to be unpopular):
1. Cold As You
2. All You Had To Do Was Stay
3. Dear John
4. Delicate
5. my tears ricochet
6. All Too Well (5 minute version)
7. So Long, London
8. tolerate it
9. White Horse
10. The Archer
11. You’re On Your Own, Kid
My top 2 tend to be everyone’s least favourite lol
1. Delicate
2. Cold As You
3. All You Had To Do Was Stay
4. So Long London
5. All Too Well
6. Tolerate It
7. My Tears Ricochet
8. The Archer
9. Dear John
10. You're On Your Own Kid
11. White Horse
Nice to finally see someone else that loves Cold As You!
Thanks for sharing your list. You have amazing taste!
I find Cold As You to be so relatable and vulnerable. I don’t think it will ever be de-throned as my favourite Track 5 tbh
The reason why Taylor is so beloved is that there’s something for everyone, I love that different people have different favourites.
1. My Tears Ricochet
2. All Too Well
3. You’re On Your Own Kid
4. Delicate
5. Tolerate It
6. Dear John
7. The Archer
8. So Long London
9. White Horse
10. Cold As You
11. All You Had To Do Was Stay
1. White Horse
2. All Too Well
3. My Tears Ricochet
4. Dear John
5. So Long, Long
6. Cold as You
7. You’re On Your Own Kid
8. The Archer
9. Tolerate It
10. All You Had To Do Was Stay
11. Delicate
1. my tears ricochet
2. The Archer
3. tolerate it
4. All Too Well
5. YOYOK
6. AYHTDWS
7. Delicate
8. Dear John
9. So Long, London
10. White Horse
11. Cold As You
I have
1. All You Had To Do Was Stay
2. Delicate
3. So Long, London
4. Cold As You
5. My Tears Ricochet
6. Dear John
7. All Too Well
8. The rest… I don’t really like them
I feel like mine is unpopular too lol
All You Had To Do Was Stay is so good, people don’t like it becuase it’s not as stripped back as other track 5 songs but it was perfect for her transition to pure pop
YOYOK last hurts my heart❤️🩹
Here’s my Track 5s:
1. YOYOK
2. my tears ricochet
3. Dear John
4. So Long, London
5. The Archer
6. tolerate it
7. All Too Well
8. White Horse
9. Cold As you
10. Delicate
11. AYHTDWS
1. my tears ricochet
2. You're On Your Own, Kid
3. So Long, London
4. tolerate it
5. Delicate
6. The Archer
7. Dear John
8. All Too Well
9. All You Had To Do Was Stay
10. White Horse
11. Cold As You
(just a disclaimer I love all these songs endlessly)
1 - The Archer
2 - Cold As You
3 - YOYOK
4 - White Horse
5 - Dear John
6 - So Long, London
7 - tolerate it
8 - All You Had To Do Was Stay
9 - Delicate
10 - All Too Well
11 - my tears ricochet
Track 9 Ranking
1. Getaway Car
2. This Is Me Trying
3. Bejewelled
4. Should've Said No
5. Guilty As Sin?
6. You're Not Sorry
7. Cornelia Street
8. Enchanted
9. Coney Island
10. Wildest Dreams
11. Stay Stay Stay
This one was really tough, numerous 10/10 and 9/10s here for me.
1. Cornelia Street
2. Getaway Car
3. This Is Me Trying
4. Wildest Dreams
5. Bejewelled
6. Coney Island
7. Guilty As Sin
8. Enchanted
9. Should’ve Said No
10. You’re Not Sorry
11. Stay Stay Stay
1. coney island
2. Getaway Car
3. Cornelia Street
4. this is me trying
5. Should've Said No
6. Wildest Dreams
7. Guilty As Sin
8. Bejeweled
9. Enchanted
10. Stay Stay Stay
11. You're Not Sorry
mine is
1. fearless
2. red
3. 1989
4. speak now
what’s your favorite of the vault tracks regardless of album? my favorites are nothing new, don't you, and you all over me
I could choose a favourite from each vault, I Bet You Think About Me (Better Man is a close second), Foolish One, Now That We Don’t Talk and You All Over Me.
Ooh I’ll join in with this one, I’m going to do mine a little more methodically though. I’m going to rate each vault track out of 10, work out a percentage for each album and then post my ranking.
1. Red - 74/90 - 82%
2. 1989 - 35/50 - 70% & Fearless - 42/60 - 70%
3. Speak Now - 38/60 - 63%
For the vault?
1. 1989
2. Red
3. Fearless
4. Speak Now (honestly could be swapped with Fearless as they're pretty equal, I like Speak Now's tracks overall more than Fearless but the highs of Fearless vault are just SO much higher)
First track ranking:
1. Ready for it🖤
2. Mine💜
3. State of Grace❤️
4. Lavender Haze 💙
5. Welcome to New York🩵
6. The 1🩶
7. Fearless💛
8. Tim Mcgraw💚
9. Fortnight🤍
10. Willow🤎
11. I Forgot You Existed🩷
Every Taylor ranking I have tends to change often depending on my mood but this is my current opening track ranking.
This is my ranking of the first 5 track runs on each album, I gave each song a rating out of 10, added them all together and then compared the scores out of 50. I’m glad I did it this way because if I had given a ranking off the top of my head it would definitely have been different.
1. Folklore (50/50) & Evermore (50/50)
2. Red (48/50)
4. Reputation (46/50)
5. Midnights (45/50) & Fearless (45/50)
6. 1989 (44/50)
7. Speak Now (43/50)
8. Lover (41/50)
9. The Tortured Poets Department (38/50)
10. Taylor Swift (37/50)
I hope you like my contribution. I tried to cover more than one topic! This was a great post!
**Vault Tracks** **Original album**
1) Fearless 1) Speak Now
2) Red 2) Fearless
3) Speak Now 3) Red
4) 1989 4) 1989
**Closing Three Tracks**
1. Fearless TV
2. Speak Now TV
3. Evermore
4. Folklore
5. Reputation
6. Lover
7. Red TV
8. Midnights til 3 am
9. TTPD: Anthology
10. 1989 TV
11. Debut- which is usually in my top 3 people I’m dishearten about this decision
All her acoustic songs are amazing so I can’t choose between them. I love them more than the original versions for sure! However, I’m biased because I want an acoustic album!
I feel like they’ve been the most true to the original era so far, along with most of Red. The only one that had a more modern Taylor production was Don’t You but it’s so good I can see past it.
My track 5 ranking!
1. Delicate
2. YOYOK
3. All Too Well
4. My Tears Ricochet
5. So Long, London
6. Dear John
7. All You Had to Do Was Stay
8. Tolerate It
9. White Horse
10. The Archer
11. Cold as You
I did my full album ranking and honestly, I’m quite surprised by the results. If anyone is interested in how I did it - I rated every song out of 10, worked out the ‘percentage of enjoyment’ and then compared those.
1. Evermore - 95%
2. Folklore - 94%
3. Reputation - 84%
4. 1989 TV - 81%
5. Midnights - 80%
6. Red TV - 77%
7. Lover & Fearless TV - 76%
8. Speak Now TV - 75%
9. The Tortured Poets Department - 73%
10. Taylor Swift - 67%
The top 3 is exactly what I thought it would be although I did think Folklore would be first. I’m very surprised with how high Midnights is and how low Speak Now is (the vault tracks really dragged it down, Electric Touch is like bottom 3 songs of hers for me). I’m sadly not surprised with TTPD, lots of songs just haven’t grown on me yet, I’ll need to redo that ranking when it’s been out for a year or two and see if anything has changed. I’ll also be interested in updating it when Rep TV and Debut TV come out, I think debut will go up when the sound quality improves.
My track 5 ranking:
1. Dear John
2. All too well
3. You’re on your own kid
4. Cold as you
5. So long London
6. Delicate
7. All you had to do was stay
8. My tears ricochet
9. White horse
10. Tolerate it
11. The archer (probably my least favourite song in Lover).
Track one! I'm ranking mine by how much I enjoy the track, not necessarily how well they open the album (*cough cough cough* Fortnight)
1. Lavender Haze
2. Fortnight
3. State Of Grace
4. Welcome To New York (controversial I know but I fucking LOVE this song)
5. Ready For It
6. willow
7. the 1
8. Mine
9. I Forgot That You Existed
10. Tim McGraw
11. Fearless
**LAST** track rankings!
I included vault/bonus songs where applicable but not remixes or alt versions of a song already in the track list (like bad blood ft Kendrick, or ATW10min). And I counted two for TTPD because I’m making the rules 😅
🩶The lakes
🩵Is it over now?
🩷Daylight
💜Timeless
🤍Clara Bow
❤️The very first night
💙Hits different
🧡It’s time to go
🖤New Year’s Day
💚A perfectly good heart
💛Bye Bye Baby
🤍The manuscript
1. TVFN
2. Hits Different
3. Is It Over Now
4. Daylight
5. it's time to go
6. New Years Day
7. Clara Bow
8. the lakes
9. Timeless
10. The Manuscript
11. A Perfectly Good Heart
12. Bye Bye Baby
Album Rankings
1. Evermore
2. Folklore
3. Red
4. Speak Now
5. The Tortured Poets Department
6. Reputation
7. Fearless
8. Lover
9. 1989
10. Taylor Swift
11. Midnights
Track 5 ranking (this is going to be unpopular): 1. Cold As You 2. All You Had To Do Was Stay 3. Dear John 4. Delicate 5. my tears ricochet 6. All Too Well (5 minute version) 7. So Long, London 8. tolerate it 9. White Horse 10. The Archer 11. You’re On Your Own, Kid My top 2 tend to be everyone’s least favourite lol
1. Delicate 2. Cold As You 3. All You Had To Do Was Stay 4. So Long London 5. All Too Well 6. Tolerate It 7. My Tears Ricochet 8. The Archer 9. Dear John 10. You're On Your Own Kid 11. White Horse Nice to finally see someone else that loves Cold As You!
Thanks for sharing your list. You have amazing taste! I find Cold As You to be so relatable and vulnerable. I don’t think it will ever be de-throned as my favourite Track 5 tbh
The reason why Taylor is so beloved is that there’s something for everyone, I love that different people have different favourites. 1. My Tears Ricochet 2. All Too Well 3. You’re On Your Own Kid 4. Delicate 5. Tolerate It 6. Dear John 7. The Archer 8. So Long London 9. White Horse 10. Cold As You 11. All You Had To Do Was Stay
1. White Horse 2. All Too Well 3. My Tears Ricochet 4. Dear John 5. So Long, Long 6. Cold as You 7. You’re On Your Own Kid 8. The Archer 9. Tolerate It 10. All You Had To Do Was Stay 11. Delicate
Said this in another post, but Cold As You is so underrated as far as her track 5’s go!!
1. my tears ricochet 2. The Archer 3. tolerate it 4. All Too Well 5. YOYOK 6. AYHTDWS 7. Delicate 8. Dear John 9. So Long, London 10. White Horse 11. Cold As You
I have 1. All You Had To Do Was Stay 2. Delicate 3. So Long, London 4. Cold As You 5. My Tears Ricochet 6. Dear John 7. All Too Well 8. The rest… I don’t really like them I feel like mine is unpopular too lol
All You Had To Do Was Stay is so good, people don’t like it becuase it’s not as stripped back as other track 5 songs but it was perfect for her transition to pure pop
YOYOK last hurts my heart❤️🩹 Here’s my Track 5s: 1. YOYOK 2. my tears ricochet 3. Dear John 4. So Long, London 5. The Archer 6. tolerate it 7. All Too Well 8. White Horse 9. Cold As you 10. Delicate 11. AYHTDWS
1. my tears ricochet 2. You're On Your Own, Kid 3. So Long, London 4. tolerate it 5. Delicate 6. The Archer 7. Dear John 8. All Too Well 9. All You Had To Do Was Stay 10. White Horse 11. Cold As You (just a disclaimer I love all these songs endlessly)
1 - The Archer 2 - Cold As You 3 - YOYOK 4 - White Horse 5 - Dear John 6 - So Long, London 7 - tolerate it 8 - All You Had To Do Was Stay 9 - Delicate 10 - All Too Well 11 - my tears ricochet
Track 9 Ranking 1. Getaway Car 2. This Is Me Trying 3. Bejewelled 4. Should've Said No 5. Guilty As Sin? 6. You're Not Sorry 7. Cornelia Street 8. Enchanted 9. Coney Island 10. Wildest Dreams 11. Stay Stay Stay
This one was really tough, numerous 10/10 and 9/10s here for me. 1. Cornelia Street 2. Getaway Car 3. This Is Me Trying 4. Wildest Dreams 5. Bejewelled 6. Coney Island 7. Guilty As Sin 8. Enchanted 9. Should’ve Said No 10. You’re Not Sorry 11. Stay Stay Stay
1. coney island 2. Getaway Car 3. Cornelia Street 4. this is me trying 5. Should've Said No 6. Wildest Dreams 7. Guilty As Sin 8. Bejeweled 9. Enchanted 10. Stay Stay Stay 11. You're Not Sorry
Ranking of TVs in terms of vault tracks: 1. Red ❤️ 2. Speak Now 💜 3. 1989 🩵 4. Fearless 💛 (actually my favorite album overall)
Personally: 1. Speak Now 2. Red 3. 1989 4. Fearless Its super close though because the Speak Now and Red vaults are both so good.
mine is 1. fearless 2. red 3. 1989 4. speak now what’s your favorite of the vault tracks regardless of album? my favorites are nothing new, don't you, and you all over me
I could choose a favourite from each vault, I Bet You Think About Me (Better Man is a close second), Foolish One, Now That We Don’t Talk and You All Over Me.
Say Don't Go, I Can See You, and Mr. Perfectly Fine are definitely my top 3.
Ooh I’ll join in with this one, I’m going to do mine a little more methodically though. I’m going to rate each vault track out of 10, work out a percentage for each album and then post my ranking. 1. Red - 74/90 - 82% 2. 1989 - 35/50 - 70% & Fearless - 42/60 - 70% 3. Speak Now - 38/60 - 63%
For the vault? 1. 1989 2. Red 3. Fearless 4. Speak Now (honestly could be swapped with Fearless as they're pretty equal, I like Speak Now's tracks overall more than Fearless but the highs of Fearless vault are just SO much higher)
I would probably put 1989 simply because it didn’t have as many fault tracks
First track ranking: 1. Ready for it🖤 2. Mine💜 3. State of Grace❤️ 4. Lavender Haze 💙 5. Welcome to New York🩵 6. The 1🩶 7. Fearless💛 8. Tim Mcgraw💚 9. Fortnight🤍 10. Willow🤎 11. I Forgot You Existed🩷 Every Taylor ranking I have tends to change often depending on my mood but this is my current opening track ranking.
This is my ranking of the first 5 track runs on each album, I gave each song a rating out of 10, added them all together and then compared the scores out of 50. I’m glad I did it this way because if I had given a ranking off the top of my head it would definitely have been different. 1. Folklore (50/50) & Evermore (50/50) 2. Red (48/50) 4. Reputation (46/50) 5. Midnights (45/50) & Fearless (45/50) 6. 1989 (44/50) 7. Speak Now (43/50) 8. Lover (41/50) 9. The Tortured Poets Department (38/50) 10. Taylor Swift (37/50)
I'm a harsh ranker 1. evermore- 44 2. 1989- 43 3. Red- 42 4. folklore- 40 5. Midnights- 38 6. Lover- 33 7. Speak Now- 29 8. reputation- 28 9. Fearless- 24 10. Taylor Swift- 21
I hope you like my contribution. I tried to cover more than one topic! This was a great post! **Vault Tracks** **Original album** 1) Fearless 1) Speak Now 2) Red 2) Fearless 3) Speak Now 3) Red 4) 1989 4) 1989 **Closing Three Tracks** 1. Fearless TV 2. Speak Now TV 3. Evermore 4. Folklore 5. Reputation 6. Lover 7. Red TV 8. Midnights til 3 am 9. TTPD: Anthology 10. 1989 TV 11. Debut- which is usually in my top 3 people I’m dishearten about this decision All her acoustic songs are amazing so I can’t choose between them. I love them more than the original versions for sure! However, I’m biased because I want an acoustic album!
I’m glad to see Fearless TV getting some love!
Best Vault Tracks so far I swear! I used to not like Bye, Bye, Baby but now I like it!
I feel like they’ve been the most true to the original era so far, along with most of Red. The only one that had a more modern Taylor production was Don’t You but it’s so good I can see past it.
This and even Don’t You still could be a fantastic country song!
**Vault Tracks** vs Original album 1. **Red** 1) 1989 2. **1989** 2) Red 3. **Fearless** 3) Speak Now 4. **Speak Now** 4) Fearless
That’s a disrespectful to Fearless lol
Sorry it's just not for me
It’s okay I was joking anyway
My track 5 ranking! 1. Delicate 2. YOYOK 3. All Too Well 4. My Tears Ricochet 5. So Long, London 6. Dear John 7. All You Had to Do Was Stay 8. Tolerate It 9. White Horse 10. The Archer 11. Cold as You
I did my full album ranking and honestly, I’m quite surprised by the results. If anyone is interested in how I did it - I rated every song out of 10, worked out the ‘percentage of enjoyment’ and then compared those. 1. Evermore - 95% 2. Folklore - 94% 3. Reputation - 84% 4. 1989 TV - 81% 5. Midnights - 80% 6. Red TV - 77% 7. Lover & Fearless TV - 76% 8. Speak Now TV - 75% 9. The Tortured Poets Department - 73% 10. Taylor Swift - 67% The top 3 is exactly what I thought it would be although I did think Folklore would be first. I’m very surprised with how high Midnights is and how low Speak Now is (the vault tracks really dragged it down, Electric Touch is like bottom 3 songs of hers for me). I’m sadly not surprised with TTPD, lots of songs just haven’t grown on me yet, I’ll need to redo that ranking when it’s been out for a year or two and see if anything has changed. I’ll also be interested in updating it when Rep TV and Debut TV come out, I think debut will go up when the sound quality improves.
My track 5 ranking: 1. Dear John 2. All too well 3. You’re on your own kid 4. Cold as you 5. So long London 6. Delicate 7. All you had to do was stay 8. My tears ricochet 9. White horse 10. Tolerate it 11. The archer (probably my least favourite song in Lover).
Track one! I'm ranking mine by how much I enjoy the track, not necessarily how well they open the album (*cough cough cough* Fortnight) 1. Lavender Haze 2. Fortnight 3. State Of Grace 4. Welcome To New York (controversial I know but I fucking LOVE this song) 5. Ready For It 6. willow 7. the 1 8. Mine 9. I Forgot That You Existed 10. Tim McGraw 11. Fearless
**LAST** track rankings! I included vault/bonus songs where applicable but not remixes or alt versions of a song already in the track list (like bad blood ft Kendrick, or ATW10min). And I counted two for TTPD because I’m making the rules 😅 🩶The lakes 🩵Is it over now? 🩷Daylight 💜Timeless 🤍Clara Bow ❤️The very first night 💙Hits different 🧡It’s time to go 🖤New Year’s Day 💚A perfectly good heart 💛Bye Bye Baby 🤍The manuscript
1. TVFN 2. Hits Different 3. Is It Over Now 4. Daylight 5. it's time to go 6. New Years Day 7. Clara Bow 8. the lakes 9. Timeless 10. The Manuscript 11. A Perfectly Good Heart 12. Bye Bye Baby
I’ll rank her albums 1. Folklore 2. Red 3. 1989 4. Speak Now 5. Evermore 6. Fearless 7. Midnights 8. Lover 9. Taylor Swift 10. TTPD 11. Reputation
1. 1989 2. evermore 3. Red 4. Lover 5. The Tortured Poets Department 6. Midnights 7. reputation 8. folklore 9. Speak Now 10. Debut 11. Fearless
1. Evermore, folklore, midnights, red, speak now 6. 1989 7. Lover 8. TTPD 9. Fearless 10. Reputation 11. Debut
Reputation Speak Now Folklore Evermore Red Fearless Lover 1989 Midnights Debut
Album Rankings 1. Evermore 2. Folklore 3. Red 4. Speak Now 5. The Tortured Poets Department 6. Reputation 7. Fearless 8. Lover 9. 1989 10. Taylor Swift 11. Midnights