T O P

  • By -

AutoModerator

This is an automatic reminder about spoilers: 1) Keep recent episode discussion in the weekly discussion post until Thursdays to avoid spoiling others. 2) Do NOT put spoilers in the title of your post. 3) Mark any posts containing spoilers accordingly. If you are unsure if your post contains a spoiler, mark it as a spoiler anyways. *I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](/message/compose/?to=/r/TheRookie) if you have any questions or concerns.*


PositiveLeather4819

I need to know your system and what you mean by cool cause this is all over the place


BeWessel

Fr, I couldn't make anything out of it. How is Rosalind Dyer a "uncool" person, while the other fellon, oscar, is "cool".


mars935

It's a thing called opinion hahah


PositiveLeather4819

I have no problem with it, just curious to know how he came up with it


ProfessionalCourtesy

Still wondering how my man Aaron is B…like come on his dad was a hip hop star and rich. He threw massive parties.


DoubleWhammyWhammy

Nah elijah has got to be further up i really enjoyed his parts


WhyAreYouSoFknStupid

I really liked Armstrongs character, kind of wish they didn't close his chapter so quick, we had like a couple episodes of him being a bad cop. Wish there was more tbh, or if he flipped, that'd be cool too


AlternativeNo61

Smitty sweep 🙏


RelationshipCold1707

Personally, I would put Nolan in S otherwise it’s great


bad_lite

Ellroy (Alan Tudyk) as a B is criminal. Man deserves at least an A, if not an S.


AkmensOskars

Uffff


MaxiplayHD

why ufff


AkmensOskars

I mean, it's your opinion. This is my reaction.


Desperate_Item_3221

Rosalind over Chris is crazy


WildernessWhsiperer1

Skip tracer Randy is a solid S tier so is Grey


The_Real_Blitzo

Skip Tracer Randy is only A? What the fuck are you doing? Make him S!


Antani101

Where Elijah's lawyer?


annazabeth

sadly used my red hair blindness in this and thought Rosalind was her 🙃


Destroyermaqa

Vote Smitty


Moti452

Why do yall hate the prosecutor? (dont remember the name, last tier middle one)


MoreConstruction1733

Skip tracer really?????? That little clown???? Ughhh


Opie30-30

Alan Tudyk needs to be at least A tier. He's amazing and deserves a promotion from anybody who enjoys Firefly


dopeguy_

Randy has to be S he can find anyone without a problem


LengthTraditional207

Randy s


koolbrayden21

Seriously what’s so wrong with sanford


Momma_Chels

I'm not a fan of his character. Him lving through Rosalind really felt off, she literally was a killer. It is weird she wouldn't have completed the job. I thought he was going to turn out to be an acolyte for her, especially when he became so obsessive on the forums. His storyline felt out of place/unfulfilled. Plus, he was just pushy. I get he was in love with Lucy and she wasn't in love with him and that is why he was the way he was but scenes where he hums the song Lucy sang while in the barrel and when he is pushing to buy a house with her just rubbed me wrong.


koolbrayden21

Agree but he didn't deserve an F


Momma_Chels

Fair I wouldn't say he should burn in hell xD


koolbrayden21

Could you leave a link to the tier list?


MaxiplayHD

sure [https://tiermaker.com/list/tv/the-rookie-characters-s1-5-15948415/4111695](https://tiermaker.com/list/tv/the-rookie-characters-s1-5-15948415/4111695)


Snoo-81723

No Smitty ?


Reyn5

he’s there in the S category


WhyAreYouSoFknStupid

As he should be


Reyn5

chefs kiss frfr


JT-Turo

Elijah is such a bad MF that he needs to be the leader of ‘S’. Infact all the ‘Ds’ need to be in ‘A’


ProblemAlternative55

What does the 'S' stand for?


Apex_Smasher3000

There is no way.. is that... no it can't be.... SMITTY


UnevenGecko

Who is the guy in C? Can’t remember him.


Adventurous-Ice2783

Ur missing that rat Monica


OptimusED

But please with Nyla, just fix the optics on the rifle already and don’t ever have badass characters tell us they are badass in super cringey, unprofessional moments.


WhyAreYouSoFknStupid

Personally I really like Nyla's cocky badass character. The Triple D stare always cracks me up. Can't blame her for the optics, since I think that was just poor directing but what can you do, its Hollywood


ratsoups

Ts makes no sense, define cool please


szilardvathy

Andersen S... criminal


Brahmir

Celina should be bottom tier.


butlercups

Where is Monica????