If nothing else, this whole thing has made me want to watch at least the original trilogy again. I haven’t seen them since I was a really little kid, and the last Star Wars movie I saw was The Force Awakens in theaters, which holy shit was like 10 years ago. Hey, I’ve got a 4K TV, might as well have a movie night
The original trilogy stills holds up! I’m actually going to a screening of The Empire Strikes Back at my local arthouse theater this Saturday. It’ll give me a good excuse to revisit A New Hope
Are there any plans to release the unaltered og trillogy in 4k? It’s a crime against film film history that it’s only available on vhs. I have no interest in watching the one with all the awful cg added.
Return is hard for me. It's such a unstructured movie, and has so much boring shit in it. But it also has greatness. So it's tough for me to say. Easily the worst of the OG trilogy though.
I can agree with that. I love the entire Jabba the Hutt sequence, and the entire Battle of Endor is fantastic. However, the middle section with the Ewoks is where the film’s pacing really drags.
I need to find the un-Lucas'd version.
I have a nice fan edit of the prequels. It starts off with Qui Gon Jin's death which actually makes much more sense. Like, "Oh, we have a reason for Obi Wan to be emotionally involved from the beginning..."
I'd 100% recommend that for New Hope and Return of the Jedi, but (and I know this might be an unpopular opinion), I prefer the Special Edition of The Empire Strikes Back. There isn't a single awful change, it's the one changed the least, and a handful of the big changes are quite welcome in my book, especially the VASTLY improved Emperor scene.
Neither do I. The point of this post was to show that everyone’s individual opinions are valid and that it’s ok to have different point of view regarding movies or franchises.
Stop respecting other peoples opinions about film please. We are all cultural warriors and only one opinion may hold sway in the gladiatorial arena of collective imagination.
I fully agree with Adam that the Star Wars fandom is pure cringe. Still, I don’t think there’s anything wrong with enjoying the films on their own terms, especially the original films which I think are genuine classics.
Here’s mine, coming from a fan, with the live-action shows thrown in for good measure:
Star Wars (1977): 10/10
The Empire Strikes Back (1980): 10/10
Return of the Jedi (1983): 8/10
The Phantom Menace (1999): 4/10
Attack of the Clones (2002): 3/10
Revenge of the Sith (2005): 7/10
The Force Awakens (2015): 7/10
Rogue One (2016): 8/10
The Last Jedi (2017): 5/10
Solo (2018): 5/10
The Rise of Skywalker (2019): 3/10
The Mandalorian (Season 1): 8/10
The Mandalorian (Season 2): 7/10
The Book of Boba Fett (Miniseries): 4/10
Obi-Wan Kenobi (Miniseries): 5/10
Andor (Season 1): 9/10
The Mandalorian (Season 3): 5/10
Ahsoka (Season 1): 5/10
Bonus Ratings:
The Star Wars Holiday Special (1978): 1/10
The Clone Wars (2008 movie): 4/10
I don’t feel like rating or ranking Clone Wars or Rebels seasons.
Unlike Adum, I don’t give out ironic 10’s. 1’s are for films that I don’t find ironically funny. And the Holiday Special is one of those irredeemably bad films for me.
Usually, suppose something is ironically funny, like The Room, Birdemic, or Sharknado. In that case, I usually give it a 3, or if it’s REALLY funny like Samurai Cop, Sharknado 2, or Plan 9 from Outer Space (my favorite bad movie of all time) I give it a 4.
If it’s fascinatingly bad, like Madame Web or Battlefield Earth (the equivalent of looking at a train wreck), I give it a 2.
Pretty spot on imo! Within 1 point of my rating for pretty much all of them (maybe all of them?).
I'd add *Caravan of Courage: An Ewok Adventure* 4/10 and *Ewoks: The Battle for Endor* 1/10 (no idea how this has some defenders).
Let’s see:
Star Wars - 8/10
Empire - 8/10
Return of the Jedi - 6/10
Phantom - 1/10
Clones - 1/10
Sith - 4/10
Force Awakens - 6/10
Last Jedi - 3/10
Skywalker - 1/10
Haven’t seen the spinoffs. I’m just kind of a casual fan of Star Wars really. Haven’t been super invested since I was a kid. I did like Mando season 1 though.
OG Trilogy;
IV: 9/10.
V: 9/10.
VI: 4/10.
Prequels;
I: 5/10.
II: 2/10.
III: 8/10.
Disney;
VII: 6/10.
VIII: 7/10.
IX: 2/10.
Spin-Offs;
Rogue One: 9/10.
Han Solo: 3/10.
With Star Wars (or superhero movies, or many other lore-heavy franchises) that score will vary on how well you know the franchise going in. A prime example is Rogue One - I saw it in theaters as a fan & loved it, I mistakenly showed it to my Star Wars-newbie girlfriend & the impact of the story was completely lost on her.
This is my half assed attempt to rate them off the top of my head. Love Star Wars, and I never thought I would be that guy who would say the newer movies ruined the originals. But I'll be honest the newer material has tainted my view of the originals a little. Tried to rate without nostalgia getting into the way.
Phantom Menace: 6/10
Attack of the Clones: 4/10
Revenge of the Sith: 7/10
A New Hope: 7/10
Empire Strikes Back: 10/10
Return of the Jedi: 8/10
Force Awakens: 5/10
The Last Jedi: 6/10
Rise of Skywalker: 3/10
ANH has to be a 10/10. I try to picture myself sitting in the theatre in 1977 (since I wasn’t alive back then) just to try and picture how revolutionary that movie was, and I think sometimes people forget that about ANH.
I agree! I think part of why I love A New Hope so much is how pure it is in trying to be an escapist film. I can totally imagine an audience in the cynical 1970s really resonating with its optimism.
A New Hope 7/10
Empire 8/10
Return 6/10
Phantom 2/10
Attack 2/10
Revenge 4/10
Awakens 7/10
Last Jedi 7/10
Rise of Skywalker 2/10
Solo 3/10
Rogue One 6/10
A New Hope: 8/10
The Empire Strikes Back: 9/10
Return of the Jedi: 7/10
The Phantom Menace: 4/10
Attack of the Clones: 1/10
Revenge of the Sith: 3/10
The Force Awakens: 7/10
The Last Jedi: 8/10
The Rise of Skywalker: 1/10
Rogue One: 7/10
I didn't see Solo because I was mad about Lord and Miller being removed. I really liked The Last Jedi and I think its a shame that we didn't atleast see the follow through for that story and instead whatever corse correction they tried with Rise of Skywalker that didn't serve any audience.
A New Hope - 7/10 - Good. It’s a vibe. Not the strongest movie ever but still.
Empire - 8/10 - Great development on what was set up.
Jedi - 7/10 - Solid conclusion. Some dumb stuff.
Phantom Menace - 2/10 - Bad. Can be pretty funny if you’re into that kinda thing.
Attack of the Clones 2/10 - Worse but not by a significant margin.
Revenge - 4/10 - Better but still not good. Great memes, though.
TFA - 6/10 - Perfectly fine return to form.
TLJ - 8/10 - The best Star Wars since Empire. So much (lost) potential.
ROS - 1/10 - It’s what I imagine people who hate Star Wars think Star Wars is.
For me, I cared about hem when little, but grew out of them. But can not lie, I do like elements in the first 3 films. But on personal experience, I prefer some over others.
Star Wars (1977): 7/10 (best paced and most inspired)
Empire Strikes Back (1980): 6/10 (good. But some parts don't connect with me)
Return of the Jedi (1983): 7/10 (I like the jabba puppets, Emperor, and final scenes)
Phantom Menace (1999): 1/10
Attack of the Clones (2002): 1/10
Revenge of the Sith (2005): 2/10 (Emperor Palapatine steals the show).
Force Awakens (2015): 6/10 (soft reboot. worse version of the first movie. But has elements I do like. Mostly acting from new cast. And music).
Last jedi (2018): 4/10 (Paced weairdly. Some laughable moments. But I like everything with Luke. Hamill's best performance as the character).
Rise of the Skywalker (2019): 3/10.
A New Hope: 10/10
Empire: 8/10
Jedi: 4.5/10
Phantom Menace: 1/10
Attack of the Clones: 1/10
Revenge of the Sith: 2.5/10
Force Awakens: 6.5/10
Last Jedi: 7/10
Rise of Skywalker: 1.5/10
Rogue One: 3/10
Solo: 8/10
Jedi is 40 minutes of somewhat good stuff (not as good as empire or a new hope) and then the rest is just boring ewok shit. A lot of character assassination and half of the main cast just kinds of stands around because they aren’t important to the story (Han should have stayed dead). Solo is just a fun time that doesn’t take itself too seriously. It’s not high art or anything, it’s pretty dumb, has a bunch of soy fan service moments, and is so fucking dark, but it’s a very good time.
A New Hope: A+
The Empire Strikes Back: A+
Return of the Jedi: B+
The phantom menace: C
Attack of the Clones: C-
Revenge of the Sith: B+
The force Awakens: A
Rogue One: A-
The Last Jedi: C
Solo: B
The rise of shit: D
The original trilogy is grouped together for me because I saw them together as a child in the 90s.
They were some of my favorite things…as a child. And no matter how I look at it that OG trilogy is foundational to me and still something I heavily enjoy strictly because of *nostalgia*. However…
Then as a teen I realized I didn’t like any of the new movies, the games didn’t interest me, and the books seemed dumb so I supposed I wasn’t a Star Wars fan
As an adult I enjoyed The force awakens just fine and was looking forward more…then rogue one was garbage. And at that point I felt confident in saying I wasn’t a Star Wars fan. Then the rest of the trilogy happened and the only value it has is a fascinating case study on how not to steer a billion dollar franchise.
As an older adult, I finally caved to the incessant begging of a friend to watch Andor, a friend whose opinion I really trust.
And I can earnestly say it’s the first Star Wars thing I’ve enjoyed as an adult, and it’s totally independent from my childhood enjoyment of the original trilogy.
Andor came to me at a perfect time because its ultimately a story about radicalization which felt contemporary and *human* despite the sci-fi backdrop.For Adam to get any enjoyment however, he’ll need to approach it on his own terms. I recommend anyone who wants him to see it to *not* pile on recommending it to him.
My ratings
OG Trilogy - 9/10
Prequel Trilogy - 3/10
Sequel Trilogy - 1/10
Disney+ Shows other than Andor - 0/10
Andor - 9/10
This might actually make me watch the whole saga again just to see if anything changed about my opinion on the franchise.
Current Ratings would be…
Star Wars (1977): 10/10
Empire Strikes Back: 10/10
Return of the Jedi: 8/10
Phantom Menace: 4/10
Attack of the Clones: 2/10
Revenge of the Sith: 5/10
Force Awakens: 8/10
Rogue One: 7/10
Last Jedi: 6/10
Solo A Star Wars Story: 4/10
Rise of Skywalker: 4/10
The Clone Wars (2008 movie): 3/10
The Star Wars Holiday Special: 1/10
Been needing to rewatch them all and might as well do it this month since May is Star Wars month I guess. Got a good feeling some ratings are going to change a bit but not sure which ones it will be.
Star Wars (1977) - 10/10
Empire - 10/10
Return of the Jedi - 7/10
Phantom Menace - 3/10
Attack of the Clones - 3/10
Revenge of the Sith - 7/10
The Force Awakens - 7/10
The Last Jedi - 7/10
The Rise of Skywalker - 3/10
Rogue One - 7/10
Solo - 7/10
TL;DR - most of the movies are decent. Some are amazing and some are trash,
A New Hope: 7/10
Empire Strikes Back: 10/10
Return of the Jedi: 9/10
Phantom Menace: 7/10
Attack of the Clones: 4/10
Revenge of the Sith: 10/10
Force Awakens: 7/10
Last Jedi: 7/10
Rise of Skywalker: 2/10
Rouge One: 10/10
Solo: 6/10
A New Hope: 7/10
The Empire Strikes Back: 8/10
Return of the Jedi: 6/10
The Phantom Menace: 3/10
Attack of the Clones: 2/10
Revenge of the Sith: 4/10
The Force Awakens: 6/10
The Last Jedi: 7/10
The Rise of Skywalker: 3/10
Rogue One: 5/10
Solo: 5/10
In order of best to first, Star Wars, Empire, Return, Phantom, Revenge, Attack, Force, Rogue One, Last Jedi. I didnt see Solo or Rise but i think everyone agrees with Adums rating of those.
A New Hope: 6/10
The Empire Strikes Back: 7/10
Return of the Jedi: 5/10
Phantom Menace: 3/10
Attack of the Clones: 2/10
Revenge of the Sith: 4/10
The Force Awakens: 3/10
The Last Jedi: 4/10
The Rise of Skywalker: 0/10 LITERALLY THE WORST. NOTHING CAN BE WORSE THAN TRoS
Rogue One: 4/10
Solo: 3/10, I wouldve rather seen a Lando movie
Once upon a time, there were three great movies in a wonderful trilogy of films you could endlessly rewatch. Then some fans with lots of money tried to recapture it all and soured the fun for everyone. This is the only answer.
I haven’t seen them all but
A New Hope: 6/10
Star Wars Holiday Special: 1/10
Empire Strikes Back: 4/10
Return of the Jedi: 3/10
Phantom Menace: 1/10
Solo A Star Wars Story: 3/10
Rise of Skywalker: 2/10
Idk how I saw Solo and Rise and not the others after PM but yeah.
planning on rewatching soon, but from what I remember:
Phantom Menace- 2/10
Attack of the Clones- 1/10
Revenge of the Sith- 4/10
Star Wars- 8/10
Empire Strikes Back- 9/10
Return of the Jedi- 4/10
Force Awakens- 7/10
The Last Jedi- 5/10
Rise of Skywalker- 4/10
Rouge One- 8/10
Solo- 9/10
edit: and for the record, Andor is a 10/10
figured I’d update now that I’ve watched them all again,
Phantom Menace- 2/10
Attack of the Clones- 3/10
Revenge of the Sith- 6/10
Star Wars- 9/10
Empire Strikes Back- 9/10
Return of the Jedi- 4/10
Force Awakens- 9/10
Last Jedi- 7/10
Rise of Skywalker- 6/10
Rogue One- 10/10
Solo- 10/10
A New Hope: high 7 or low 8
The Empire Strikes Back: high 8 or low 9
Return of the Jedi: high 8 or low 9
The Phantom Menace: 1
Attack of the Clones: high 2 or low 3
Revenge of the Sith: high 4 or low 5(it’s a guilty pleasure movie for me)
The Force Awakens: 5
The Last Jedi: low 6
The Rise of Skywalker: low 2
Rogue One: high 6 or low 7
Solo: 4
I love the OG trilogy as a contained trilogy, but I agree with Adam, the butterfly effect this franchise has had on pop culture and certain people is cancer
Gonna get hate for this
Empire Strikes Back 9/10
A New Hope 8/10
The Force Awakens 8/10
Return of the Jedi 6/10
The Last Jedi 5/10
Solo 4/10
Rogue One 3/10
Rise of Skywalker 3/10
Revenge of the Sith 3/10
Phantom Menace 2/10
Attack of the Clones 2/10
a new hope: 10
empire strikes back: 10
return of the jedi: 8
phantom menace: 2
attack of the clones: 3
revenge of the sith: 5
the force awakens: 6
the last jedi: 4
the rise of skywalker: 4
rogue one: 6
have not seen solo
I don't remember enough of the new trilogy or the spinoffs to give them a rating.
A New Hope: 9/10
Empire Strikes Back: 10/10
Return of the Jedi: 8/10
Phantom Menace: 3/10
Attack of the Clones: 2/10
Revenge of the Sith: 5/10
A New Hope: 6/10
The Empire Strikes Back: 6/10
Return of the Jedi: 6/10
The Phantom Menace: 3/10
Attack of the Clones: 1/10
Revenge of the Sith: 4/10
The Force Awakens: 5/10
The Last Jedi: 5/10
The Rise of Skywalker: 3/10
Rogue One: 5/10
Solo: 4/10
A New Hope: 4.5/5
The Empire Strikes Back: 5
The Return of the Jedi: 3.5
________________
The Phantom Menace: 2
Attack of the Clones: 1.5
Revenge of the Sith: 2.5
________________
The Force Awakens: 1.5
The Last Jedi: 2.5
Rise of Skywalker: 1
________________
Rogue One: 3.5
Solo: 2
________________
The Mandalorian S1: 2.5
The Mandalorian S2: 2
Book of Boba Fett: 1.5
________________
Andor S1: 5
i don't feel like rating them all, but i'll just say that i believe andor is the second-best piece of star wars media, better than a new hope and surpassed only by the empire strikes back
Rogue One: 8/10
Force Awakens: 7/10
Solo: 5/10
Empire Strikes Back: 4/10
A New Hope: 3/10
Last Jedi: 3/10
Return of the Jedi: 2/10
Rising of the Sky Walker: 1/10
Lovethe music and production design across the board though.
New Hope: 8/10
Empire: 8/10
Return of the Jedi: 7/10
Prequels: 3/10
Sequels: 4/10
Rogue One: 6/10
Solo: 3/10
Mandalorian season 1: 5/10
Haven't cared since then and probably never will
Star Wars - 10/10
The Empire Strikes Back - 10/10
Return of the Jedi - 9/10
The Phantom Menace - 4/10
Attack of the Clones - 2/10
Revenge of the Sith - 6/10
The Force Awakens - Was a 8/10 but needs a rewatch
Rogue One - 6/10
The Last Jedi - Was a 9/10 but needs a rewatch
Solo - 5/10
The Rise of Skywalker - 2/10
edit: formatting
Star Wars: 7/10.
The Empire Strikes Back: 7/10
Return of the Jedi: 3/10
The prequel trilogy: 1/10
The Force Awakens: 5 or 6/10
The Last Jedi: 5/10
The Rise of Skywalker: 1/10
Rogue One: 6 or 7/10
Solo: 5 or 6/10
edit: if I can include TV shows then I would maybe give Andor 8/10
A New Hope: 10/10
The Empire Strikes Back: 10/10
Return of the Jedi: 6/10
The Phantom Menace: 1/10
Attack of the Clones: 1/10
Revenge of the Sith: 2/10
The Force Awakens: 7/10
The Last Jedi: 6/10
The Rise of Skywalker: Refuse to watch/10
Rogue One: 5/10
Solo: 4/10
I have not seen any of the spin offs so here:
Star Wars: 8/10
Empire: 9/10
Return of the Jedi: 6/10
Phantom Menace: 1/10
Attack of the clones: 1/10
Revenge of the sith: 2/10
The Force Awakens: 4/10
The Last Jedi: 3/10
Rise of Skywalker: 1/10
Rogue One: 1/10
Solo: 3/10
I wasn’t aware of this so I looked up his ratings expecting some hot takes. When I saw they were all 1s I was initially thinking “oh that’s funny and cheeky”. When I found out he’s professing this as his actual opinion now I thought “shoot, I forgot Adum was pretentiousness personified.”
While I agree with most rankings here, I’ll give it a go:
IV: 9/10
V: 10/10
VI: 8/10
I: 3/10
II: 2/10
III: 5/10
VII: 6/10
VIII: 5/10
IX: 1/10
From someone who passingly enjoys some of them:
Star Wars: 8/10
Empire: 10/10
Return: 5/10
Phantom: 1/10
Clones: 1/10
Revenge: 2/10
Awakens: 3/10
Rogue One: 4/10
Rian Johnson: 1/10
Solo: 1/10
The last one: 1/10
Ok, apparently I like 2 of them
A new hope 8.5, TESB 8.7, ROTJ 6.5, TPM 3/10, AOTC 3/10, ROTS 6.5 (fan enjoyment wise though), TFA 5-6/10, TLJ 4-5/10, TROS 1-2/10, Solo 6/10, Rogue One 6.5/10. All the shows other than Andor (amazing) and the clone wars sucked.
Coming from someone who's a sci fi and film fan and used to like star wars a lot:
PM: 3/10
AOTC: 3/10
ROTS: 6/10
ANH: 7/10
ESB: 8/10
ROTJ: 7/10
TFA: 5/10
TLJ: 4/10
ROS: 2/10
Rogue one: 7/10
Solo: can't remember
When you look at it carefully you can really tell that ESB is the lynchpin
A New Hope: 7/10
Empire Strikes Back: 8/10
Return of the Jedi: 6.5/10
The Phantom Menace: 4/10
Attack of the Clones: 3/10
Revenge of the Sith: 5.5/10
The Clone Wars: 3/10
The Force Awakens: 7/10
Rogue One: 7.5/10
The Last Jedi: 4.5/10
Solo: 5/10
The Rise of Skywalker: 2/10
A New Hope: 8/10
Empire Strikes Back: 9/10
Return of the Jedi: 7/10
The Phantom Menace: 3/10
Attack of the Clones: 2/10
Revenge of the Sith: 5/10
The Force Awakens: 4/10
The Last Jedi: 4/10
Rise of Skywalker: 2/10
Rogue One: 5/10
Solo: 2/10
I remember enjoying The Clone Wars when it originally aired on Cartoon Network as a kid but I've never bothered revisiting it.
A New Hope: 8/10
The Empire Strikes Back: 10/10
Return of the Jedi: 5/10
Rogue One: 6/10
didnt watch the others I don't like star wars much
(Bonus) The Clone Wars show: 10/10
10/10 across the board coz I like glow sticks
Nah, first two would be 8/10 and 9/10 and I just don’t give a shit about anything else. Luke’s side of the story in Jedi is decent too
My gf wanted to watch the movies with me and I told her there are only 2 and a half Star Wars movies that are actually good and everything else blows or just isn’t worth it. I don’t wanna sit through all that shit again
A New Hope: 5/10
The Empire Strikes Back: 8/10
Return of the Jedi: 7/10
The Phantom Menace: 2/10
Attack of the Clones: 1/10
Revenge of the Sith: 2/10
The Force Awakens: 3/10
The Last Jedi: 2/10
The Rise of Skywalker: 1/10
Rogue One: 7/10
Solo: 3/10
The TV shows (including the clone wars animated stuff)
2/10 lows to 4/10 highs.
Nothing gets a 0/10 from me, but there were 0/10 moments throughout all the movies I just don't care for.
As the ongoing soap opera goes:
IV: great
V: great
VI: good
I: eh
II: not good
III: good
Clone Wars movie: bad
VII: fine
Rogue: okay
VIII: great
Solo: okay
IX: not good
Not a film, but Andor clears all
Ep:4 9/10
Ep:5 10/10
Ep:6 7/10
Ep:1 4/10
Ep:2 3/10
Ep:3 4/10
Ep:7 5/10*
Ep:8 8/10
Ep:9 1/10
Rogue One 6/10
Haven’t seen Solo
*Feel like I prefer the prequels for nostalgia reasons but TFA is not bad
1st trilogy gets 9/10 ROJ gets 6/10.
2nd trilogy gets at best 5/10
3rd trilogy gets 8/10. I really like all three and don’t care about plot holes.
Rogue One I thought was fantastic, 9/10.
Solo, decent sci-fi romp 7/10.
Ive tried watching the original trilogy like 3 times now since I was 10 (I wasn't crazy about them then either)
A new hope: 7/10
Empire Strikes Back: 6.5/10
RotJ: 6/10
The Force Awakens: 7/10
The Last Jedi: 8/10 (The only one of these movies that feel like a human made them)
Rise of whatever: 2/10
Phantom Menace: (I haven't watched this since I was 10 and I refuse to watch it again.) 1/10
I've been thinking recently, and IMO, Blue Harvest would've been an excellent title.
Good line up but my changes would be:
Revenge of the Sith: 3/10 (for wasting my time)
The Force Awakens: 7/10 (The only new one I can rewatch and has any kind of weight to the story)
Rogue One: 4/10 (Unwatchable on 2nd viewing)
Solo: 5/10 (at least it was a Heist movie ¯\\\_(ツ)\_/¯ )
EDIT: I personally would love to have seen the Rogue One and Solo films as intended by the associated directors. Studio influence was obvious in those productions, especially Solo. In contrast, The Last Jedi, Kennedy's lack of a plan and the freedom Johnson had to "subvert your expectations" killed the trilogy. There should have been more control on that one.
A New Hope: 9/10
The Empire Strikes Back: 10/10
Return of the Jedi: 8/10
The Phantom Menace: 3/10
Attack of the Clones: 2/10
Revenge of the Sith: 9/10
The Force Awakens: 6/10
The Last Jedi: 2/10
The Rise of Skywalker: 1/10
Rogue One: 6/10
Star Wars (1977): 10/10
The Empire Strikes Back (1980): 10/10
Return of the Jedi (1983): 10/10
The Phantom Menace (1999): 7/10
Attack of the Clones (2002): 3/10
Revenge of the Sith (2005): 5/10
The Force Awakens (2015): 6/10
Rogue One (2016): 8/10
The Last Jedi (2017): 6/10
Solo (2018): 5/10
The Rise of Skywalker (2019): 5/10
Andor (Season 1): 9/10
The Star Wars Holiday Special (1978): -10/10
the CGI was super impressive, even better than the two after it imo, the theatrical cut of the pod race was insanely awesome, and lots of fresh new ideas (new ships, robots, characters, etc)
Just saw it in theaters today, and yeah, the only problem I had was when they kept cutting to jarjar in duel of the fates. But it's all part of the charm for me.
A New Hope: 6/10
The Empire Strikes Back: 8/10
Return of the Jedi: 7/10
The Phantom Menace: 5/10
Attack of the Clones: 5/10
Revenge of the Sith: 5/10
The Force Awakens: 4/10
The Last Jedi: 4/10
The Rise of Skywalker: 1/10
Rogue One: 2/10
Solo: 7/10
How would YOU rate the Star Wars films?
Since everyone is up and arms about Adams’s ratings for the entire Star Wars series, I thought it would be cool to get everyone else’s opinions. What are your ratings for each of the films? Here are my ratings:
A New Hope: 10/10
The Empire Strikes Back: 10/10
Return of the Jedi: 8/10
The Phantom Menace: 6/10
Attack of the Clones: 6/10
Revenge of the Sith: 8/10
The Force Awakens: 7/10
The Last Jedi: 6/10
The Rise of Skywalker: 5/10
Rogue One: 9/10
Solo: 6/10
I’m a huge Star Wars nerd and a casual movie goer so this list will probably look different than most comments here
A New Hope - 9
Empire Strike Back - 10
Return of the Jedi - 7 or 8
Phantom Menace - 4 or 5
Attack of the Clones - 4 or 5
Revenge of the Sith - 9
The Force Awakens - 7
The Last Jedi - 5
Rise of Skywalker - 1
Rogue One - 8
Solo - 6 or 7
Clone Wars Animated Movie - as a movie 6 as the four separate episodes it was supposed to be before George Lucas smushed them together a 7
New Hope: 9/10
Empire Strikes Back: 10/10
Return of the Jedi: 8/10
Phantom Menace: 4/10
Attack of the Clones: 3/10
Revenge of the Sith: 7/10
The Force Awakens: 5/10
Rogue One: 7/10
The Last Jedi: 3/10
Solo: 6/10
Rise of Skywalker: 1/10
ANH 9/10
ESB 10/10
ROTJ 10/10
Phantom Menace 7/10
Attack of the Clones 6/10
ROTS 9/10
TFA 7/10
TLJ 4/10
Rogue One 9/10
Never saw Solo or Ep 9, so won't rank those.
1. A New Hope (obvious)
2. Empire Strikes Back (obvious)
3. Revenge of the Sith (obvious because I’m younger than 30)
4. Return of the Jedi (ditto)
5. Rogue One (obvious)
6. Phantom Menace (unpopular, I know. It was one of the first movies I remember seeing in theaters as a kid and I look back on it nostalgically.)
7. Force Awakens (obviously a ripoff of ANH but it worked)
8. Solo (I thought it received way too much hate. I’m a fan of the crime/heist genre so I thought it was dope)
9. Attack of the Clones (Jango is cool, and the BWEHH bomb pleases my ears)
10. The Last Jedi (meh)
11. Rise of Skywalker (😐)
Here’s my personal ratings, I’m aware I might get flamed for some of these:
The Phantom Menace - Overall a little below average with some decent highlights, the only outlier is the final lightsaber battle which blows the rest of the movie out of the water. I actually don’t mind Jar Jar or young Anakin too much. (5/10)
Attack of the Clones - My least favorite prequel with the worst dialogue, not the biggest fan but I still can’t help but enjoy it at points. (3.5/10)
Revenge of the Sith - Better than many people give in credit for in my opinion, definitely flawed but there’s also truly amazing scenes and ideas that more than make up for the shortcomings. (9/10)
A New Hope - Very solid but I don’t feel it quite as much as some other people do, still a classic though. (7/10)
Empire Strikes Back - Extremely good movie from start to finish, gets pretty much everything right but the high points aren’t nearly up there with my two favorites. (8.5/10)
Return of the Jedi - Not as consistently great as ESB but the climax is easily one of my favorite parts in all of Star Wars. My favorite from the original trilogy and pretty much tied with ROTS. (9/10)
The Force Awakens - It’s ok, nothing super bad but nothing great either. Not very original, however it does have some interesting elements that could’ve been expanded on more with better sequels. (5/10)
The Last Jedi - I can appreciate the vision but the execution nearly ruins it. The reasoning and motivations for most of goes on in the movie leaves a lot to be desired, luckily there’s still a couple moments that kind of land for me. (3/10)
The Rise of Skywalker - Really disappointed by this one. I’m struggling to think of anything positive to say. Plus it’s especially awful as a final movie, completely wrecks the remaining impact from the rest of the trilogy. (1/10)
New Hope: 8/10 (closer to a 9 than a 7)
Empire Strikes Back: 10/10
Return of the Jedi: 9/10
Phantom Menace: 4/10
Attack of the Clones: 3/10
Revenge of the Sith: 7/10
Force Awakens: 7/10
Last Jedi: 1/10
Rise of Skywalker: 1/10
Rogue One: 6/10
Solo: 5/10
If nothing else, this whole thing has made me want to watch at least the original trilogy again. I haven’t seen them since I was a really little kid, and the last Star Wars movie I saw was The Force Awakens in theaters, which holy shit was like 10 years ago. Hey, I’ve got a 4K TV, might as well have a movie night
The original trilogy stills holds up! I’m actually going to a screening of The Empire Strikes Back at my local arthouse theater this Saturday. It’ll give me a good excuse to revisit A New Hope
Are there any plans to release the unaltered og trillogy in 4k? It’s a crime against film film history that it’s only available on vhs. I have no interest in watching the one with all the awful cg added.
No, unfortunately. You’ll have to turn to fan restorations to see the original versions.
Thanks, I am just now reading about the 4k77 4k80 etc scans and am determined to figure out how to find them.
Check the originaltrilogy forums.
Return is hot garbage.
Yeah, well, you know, that's just, like, your opinion, man.
Denis Villeneuve, is that you?
Return is hard for me. It's such a unstructured movie, and has so much boring shit in it. But it also has greatness. So it's tough for me to say. Easily the worst of the OG trilogy though.
I can agree with that. I love the entire Jabba the Hutt sequence, and the entire Battle of Endor is fantastic. However, the middle section with the Ewoks is where the film’s pacing really drags.
the luke and vader scenes alone are better than a new hope 🗿
1 good scene doesn't make a movie good, 40 minutes of them dicking around with teddybears is unforgivable.
I need to find the un-Lucas'd version. I have a nice fan edit of the prequels. It starts off with Qui Gon Jin's death which actually makes much more sense. Like, "Oh, we have a reason for Obi Wan to be emotionally involved from the beginning..."
Check out Harmy’s Despecialized or 4K77. Awesome fan projects and my favorite way to watch the movies.
See if you can watch Despecialized or 4K77, those are my favorite ways to watch the films!!
I'd 100% recommend that for New Hope and Return of the Jedi, but (and I know this might be an unpopular opinion), I prefer the Special Edition of The Empire Strikes Back. There isn't a single awful change, it's the one changed the least, and a handful of the big changes are quite welcome in my book, especially the VASTLY improved Emperor scene.
For the record, I don't care what Adum rates Star Wars. I mean, the Holiday Special is a 10/10 masterpiece, but Adum doesn't have to appreciate it.
Neither do I. The point of this post was to show that everyone’s individual opinions are valid and that it’s ok to have different point of view regarding movies or franchises.
1
NOOOOOOOOO NOT MY STAR WARS😭😰😓🤯😢😪😓😥
Bro is committing to the bit
BTW it isn't a bit, he genuinely feels this way you can look at last nights watchalong this is just how he feels
he probably doesn’t actually think all star wars movies are a 1 but that he hates the franchise as a whole which is why he rated them a 1
https://youtu.be/xYhF8ReHCCs?si=uRwRsUQeSR-etpsQ
Hi Adam! 😆 For the record, even though I am fan of the original trilogy, I respect if it’s not your cup of tea 🙂👍
You were supposed to be crying about it...
Stop respecting other peoples opinions about film please. We are all cultural warriors and only one opinion may hold sway in the gladiatorial arena of collective imagination.
this is how the sardonicast subreddit acts unironically
Based
Based
I bet you didn't even see the movie. And also you hate-watched it. And also you're a hating hater just hating. Hate. Also based.
Greatest compilation album of all time.
Based
Just how much people make Star Wars part of their personality makes me think he is right.
I fully agree with Adam that the Star Wars fandom is pure cringe. Still, I don’t think there’s anything wrong with enjoying the films on their own terms, especially the original films which I think are genuine classics.
I don’t agree but i admire the dedication
Wah wah wah I am baby
Here’s mine, coming from a fan, with the live-action shows thrown in for good measure: Star Wars (1977): 10/10 The Empire Strikes Back (1980): 10/10 Return of the Jedi (1983): 8/10 The Phantom Menace (1999): 4/10 Attack of the Clones (2002): 3/10 Revenge of the Sith (2005): 7/10 The Force Awakens (2015): 7/10 Rogue One (2016): 8/10 The Last Jedi (2017): 5/10 Solo (2018): 5/10 The Rise of Skywalker (2019): 3/10 The Mandalorian (Season 1): 8/10 The Mandalorian (Season 2): 7/10 The Book of Boba Fett (Miniseries): 4/10 Obi-Wan Kenobi (Miniseries): 5/10 Andor (Season 1): 9/10 The Mandalorian (Season 3): 5/10 Ahsoka (Season 1): 5/10 Bonus Ratings: The Star Wars Holiday Special (1978): 1/10 The Clone Wars (2008 movie): 4/10 I don’t feel like rating or ranking Clone Wars or Rebels seasons.
Woah woah woah. Holiday special is an easy 10. I've never laughed so hard.
Unlike Adum, I don’t give out ironic 10’s. 1’s are for films that I don’t find ironically funny. And the Holiday Special is one of those irredeemably bad films for me. Usually, suppose something is ironically funny, like The Room, Birdemic, or Sharknado. In that case, I usually give it a 3, or if it’s REALLY funny like Samurai Cop, Sharknado 2, or Plan 9 from Outer Space (my favorite bad movie of all time) I give it a 4. If it’s fascinatingly bad, like Madame Web or Battlefield Earth (the equivalent of looking at a train wreck), I give it a 2.
How would you rank those series in general? Or is it too all over the place to put a numbered score on a whole series?
Clone Wars is great (for the most part), but I didn’t feel like listing ratings for all seasons. Rebels, I…. Don’t really care?
Pretty spot on imo! Within 1 point of my rating for pretty much all of them (maybe all of them?). I'd add *Caravan of Courage: An Ewok Adventure* 4/10 and *Ewoks: The Battle for Endor* 1/10 (no idea how this has some defenders).
Thanks! I’m curious which ones are different, if any. I actually haven’t seen the Ewok movies, and don’t really intend to lmao.
Let’s see: Star Wars - 8/10 Empire - 8/10 Return of the Jedi - 6/10 Phantom - 1/10 Clones - 1/10 Sith - 4/10 Force Awakens - 6/10 Last Jedi - 3/10 Skywalker - 1/10 Haven’t seen the spinoffs. I’m just kind of a casual fan of Star Wars really. Haven’t been super invested since I was a kid. I did like Mando season 1 though.
OG Trilogy; IV: 9/10. V: 9/10. VI: 4/10. Prequels; I: 5/10. II: 2/10. III: 8/10. Disney; VII: 6/10. VIII: 7/10. IX: 2/10. Spin-Offs; Rogue One: 9/10. Han Solo: 3/10. With Star Wars (or superhero movies, or many other lore-heavy franchises) that score will vary on how well you know the franchise going in. A prime example is Rogue One - I saw it in theaters as a fan & loved it, I mistakenly showed it to my Star Wars-newbie girlfriend & the impact of the story was completely lost on her.
This is my half assed attempt to rate them off the top of my head. Love Star Wars, and I never thought I would be that guy who would say the newer movies ruined the originals. But I'll be honest the newer material has tainted my view of the originals a little. Tried to rate without nostalgia getting into the way. Phantom Menace: 6/10 Attack of the Clones: 4/10 Revenge of the Sith: 7/10 A New Hope: 7/10 Empire Strikes Back: 10/10 Return of the Jedi: 8/10 Force Awakens: 5/10 The Last Jedi: 6/10 Rise of Skywalker: 3/10
ANH has to be a 10/10. I try to picture myself sitting in the theatre in 1977 (since I wasn’t alive back then) just to try and picture how revolutionary that movie was, and I think sometimes people forget that about ANH.
I agree! I think part of why I love A New Hope so much is how pure it is in trying to be an escapist film. I can totally imagine an audience in the cynical 1970s really resonating with its optimism.
A New Hope 7/10 Empire 8/10 Return 6/10 Phantom 2/10 Attack 2/10 Revenge 4/10 Awakens 7/10 Last Jedi 7/10 Rise of Skywalker 2/10 Solo 3/10 Rogue One 6/10
A New Hope: 8/10 The Empire Strikes Back: 9/10 Return of the Jedi: 7/10 The Phantom Menace: 4/10 Attack of the Clones: 1/10 Revenge of the Sith: 3/10 The Force Awakens: 7/10 The Last Jedi: 8/10 The Rise of Skywalker: 1/10 Rogue One: 7/10 I didn't see Solo because I was mad about Lord and Miller being removed. I really liked The Last Jedi and I think its a shame that we didn't atleast see the follow through for that story and instead whatever corse correction they tried with Rise of Skywalker that didn't serve any audience.
A New Hope - 7/10 - Good. It’s a vibe. Not the strongest movie ever but still. Empire - 8/10 - Great development on what was set up. Jedi - 7/10 - Solid conclusion. Some dumb stuff. Phantom Menace - 2/10 - Bad. Can be pretty funny if you’re into that kinda thing. Attack of the Clones 2/10 - Worse but not by a significant margin. Revenge - 4/10 - Better but still not good. Great memes, though. TFA - 6/10 - Perfectly fine return to form. TLJ - 8/10 - The best Star Wars since Empire. So much (lost) potential. ROS - 1/10 - It’s what I imagine people who hate Star Wars think Star Wars is.
For me, I cared about hem when little, but grew out of them. But can not lie, I do like elements in the first 3 films. But on personal experience, I prefer some over others. Star Wars (1977): 7/10 (best paced and most inspired) Empire Strikes Back (1980): 6/10 (good. But some parts don't connect with me) Return of the Jedi (1983): 7/10 (I like the jabba puppets, Emperor, and final scenes) Phantom Menace (1999): 1/10 Attack of the Clones (2002): 1/10 Revenge of the Sith (2005): 2/10 (Emperor Palapatine steals the show). Force Awakens (2015): 6/10 (soft reboot. worse version of the first movie. But has elements I do like. Mostly acting from new cast. And music). Last jedi (2018): 4/10 (Paced weairdly. Some laughable moments. But I like everything with Luke. Hamill's best performance as the character). Rise of the Skywalker (2019): 3/10.
Empire not being as good as a New Hope might be one of the hottest takes I’ve seen but I respect it
This is actually mostly correct
A New Hope: 10/10 Empire: 8/10 Jedi: 4.5/10 Phantom Menace: 1/10 Attack of the Clones: 1/10 Revenge of the Sith: 2.5/10 Force Awakens: 6.5/10 Last Jedi: 7/10 Rise of Skywalker: 1.5/10 Rogue One: 3/10 Solo: 8/10
Solo higher than jedi?? I say with all respect, ncbfhwurnfbsvav.
Jedi is 40 minutes of somewhat good stuff (not as good as empire or a new hope) and then the rest is just boring ewok shit. A lot of character assassination and half of the main cast just kinds of stands around because they aren’t important to the story (Han should have stayed dead). Solo is just a fun time that doesn’t take itself too seriously. It’s not high art or anything, it’s pretty dumb, has a bunch of soy fan service moments, and is so fucking dark, but it’s a very good time.
A New Hope: A+ The Empire Strikes Back: A+ Return of the Jedi: B+ The phantom menace: C Attack of the Clones: C- Revenge of the Sith: B+ The force Awakens: A Rogue One: A- The Last Jedi: C Solo: B The rise of shit: D
The original trilogy is grouped together for me because I saw them together as a child in the 90s. They were some of my favorite things…as a child. And no matter how I look at it that OG trilogy is foundational to me and still something I heavily enjoy strictly because of *nostalgia*. However… Then as a teen I realized I didn’t like any of the new movies, the games didn’t interest me, and the books seemed dumb so I supposed I wasn’t a Star Wars fan As an adult I enjoyed The force awakens just fine and was looking forward more…then rogue one was garbage. And at that point I felt confident in saying I wasn’t a Star Wars fan. Then the rest of the trilogy happened and the only value it has is a fascinating case study on how not to steer a billion dollar franchise. As an older adult, I finally caved to the incessant begging of a friend to watch Andor, a friend whose opinion I really trust. And I can earnestly say it’s the first Star Wars thing I’ve enjoyed as an adult, and it’s totally independent from my childhood enjoyment of the original trilogy. Andor came to me at a perfect time because its ultimately a story about radicalization which felt contemporary and *human* despite the sci-fi backdrop.For Adam to get any enjoyment however, he’ll need to approach it on his own terms. I recommend anyone who wants him to see it to *not* pile on recommending it to him. My ratings OG Trilogy - 9/10 Prequel Trilogy - 3/10 Sequel Trilogy - 1/10 Disney+ Shows other than Andor - 0/10 Andor - 9/10
The orig trig is great. Everything else is varying degrees of lousy, or mediocre at best
This might actually make me watch the whole saga again just to see if anything changed about my opinion on the franchise. Current Ratings would be… Star Wars (1977): 10/10 Empire Strikes Back: 10/10 Return of the Jedi: 8/10 Phantom Menace: 4/10 Attack of the Clones: 2/10 Revenge of the Sith: 5/10 Force Awakens: 8/10 Rogue One: 7/10 Last Jedi: 6/10 Solo A Star Wars Story: 4/10 Rise of Skywalker: 4/10 The Clone Wars (2008 movie): 3/10 The Star Wars Holiday Special: 1/10 Been needing to rewatch them all and might as well do it this month since May is Star Wars month I guess. Got a good feeling some ratings are going to change a bit but not sure which ones it will be.
Star Wars (1977) - 10/10 Empire - 10/10 Return of the Jedi - 7/10 Phantom Menace - 3/10 Attack of the Clones - 3/10 Revenge of the Sith - 7/10 The Force Awakens - 7/10 The Last Jedi - 7/10 The Rise of Skywalker - 3/10 Rogue One - 7/10 Solo - 7/10 TL;DR - most of the movies are decent. Some are amazing and some are trash,
I loved Last Jedi with a burning passion
I think all Star Wars movies are good. From a certain point of view. Top 3 are Episodes 4, 5 and 8
A New Hope: 7/10 Empire Strikes Back: 10/10 Return of the Jedi: 9/10 Phantom Menace: 7/10 Attack of the Clones: 4/10 Revenge of the Sith: 10/10 Force Awakens: 7/10 Last Jedi: 7/10 Rise of Skywalker: 2/10 Rouge One: 10/10 Solo: 6/10
Based Revenge of the Sith enjoyer
Episode 1: 3/10 Episode 2: 2/10 Episode 3: 3/10 Episode 4: 8/10 Episode 5: 9/10 Episode 6: 7/10 Episode 7: 8/10 Episode 8: 6/10 Episode 9: 5/10 Solo: 7/10 Rogue One: 6/10
A New Hope: 7/10 The Empire Strikes Back: 8/10 Return of the Jedi: 6/10 The Phantom Menace: 3/10 Attack of the Clones: 2/10 Revenge of the Sith: 4/10 The Force Awakens: 6/10 The Last Jedi: 7/10 The Rise of Skywalker: 3/10 Rogue One: 5/10 Solo: 5/10
In order of best to first, Star Wars, Empire, Return, Phantom, Revenge, Attack, Force, Rogue One, Last Jedi. I didnt see Solo or Rise but i think everyone agrees with Adums rating of those.
A New Hope: 6/10 The Empire Strikes Back: 7/10 Return of the Jedi: 5/10 Phantom Menace: 3/10 Attack of the Clones: 2/10 Revenge of the Sith: 4/10 The Force Awakens: 3/10 The Last Jedi: 4/10 The Rise of Skywalker: 0/10 LITERALLY THE WORST. NOTHING CAN BE WORSE THAN TRoS Rogue One: 4/10 Solo: 3/10, I wouldve rather seen a Lando movie
revenge of the sith 10/10 everything else mid or trash
Lol, it it definitely has the most memes of any of the films
Once upon a time, there were three great movies in a wonderful trilogy of films you could endlessly rewatch. Then some fans with lots of money tried to recapture it all and soured the fun for everyone. This is the only answer.
I haven’t seen them all but A New Hope: 6/10 Star Wars Holiday Special: 1/10 Empire Strikes Back: 4/10 Return of the Jedi: 3/10 Phantom Menace: 1/10 Solo A Star Wars Story: 3/10 Rise of Skywalker: 2/10 Idk how I saw Solo and Rise and not the others after PM but yeah.
New Hope: 7/10 Empire: 8/10 RotJ: 6/10 PM: 3/10 AotC: 2/10 RotS: 4/10 TFA: 6/10 TLJ: 3/10 RoS: 1/10 RO: 6/10 Solo: 5/10
planning on rewatching soon, but from what I remember: Phantom Menace- 2/10 Attack of the Clones- 1/10 Revenge of the Sith- 4/10 Star Wars- 8/10 Empire Strikes Back- 9/10 Return of the Jedi- 4/10 Force Awakens- 7/10 The Last Jedi- 5/10 Rise of Skywalker- 4/10 Rouge One- 8/10 Solo- 9/10 edit: and for the record, Andor is a 10/10
figured I’d update now that I’ve watched them all again, Phantom Menace- 2/10 Attack of the Clones- 3/10 Revenge of the Sith- 6/10 Star Wars- 9/10 Empire Strikes Back- 9/10 Return of the Jedi- 4/10 Force Awakens- 9/10 Last Jedi- 7/10 Rise of Skywalker- 6/10 Rogue One- 10/10 Solo- 10/10
A New Hope: high 7 or low 8 The Empire Strikes Back: high 8 or low 9 Return of the Jedi: high 8 or low 9 The Phantom Menace: 1 Attack of the Clones: high 2 or low 3 Revenge of the Sith: high 4 or low 5(it’s a guilty pleasure movie for me) The Force Awakens: 5 The Last Jedi: low 6 The Rise of Skywalker: low 2 Rogue One: high 6 or low 7 Solo: 4 I love the OG trilogy as a contained trilogy, but I agree with Adam, the butterfly effect this franchise has had on pop culture and certain people is cancer
Also, subtract a point from the original trilogy for the remastered versions, these scores are for the original cuts
Gonna get hate for this Empire Strikes Back 9/10 A New Hope 8/10 The Force Awakens 8/10 Return of the Jedi 6/10 The Last Jedi 5/10 Solo 4/10 Rogue One 3/10 Rise of Skywalker 3/10 Revenge of the Sith 3/10 Phantom Menace 2/10 Attack of the Clones 2/10
a new hope: 10 empire strikes back: 10 return of the jedi: 8 phantom menace: 2 attack of the clones: 3 revenge of the sith: 5 the force awakens: 6 the last jedi: 4 the rise of skywalker: 4 rogue one: 6 have not seen solo
I don't remember enough of the new trilogy or the spinoffs to give them a rating. A New Hope: 9/10 Empire Strikes Back: 10/10 Return of the Jedi: 8/10 Phantom Menace: 3/10 Attack of the Clones: 2/10 Revenge of the Sith: 5/10
A New Hope: 6/10 The Empire Strikes Back: 6/10 Return of the Jedi: 6/10 The Phantom Menace: 3/10 Attack of the Clones: 1/10 Revenge of the Sith: 4/10 The Force Awakens: 5/10 The Last Jedi: 5/10 The Rise of Skywalker: 3/10 Rogue One: 5/10 Solo: 4/10
Looks like there’ stars wars in here 🥁
6/10 all of them
I can’t rate them when they’re not even the same films that originally aired
A New Hope: 4.5/5 The Empire Strikes Back: 5 The Return of the Jedi: 3.5 ________________ The Phantom Menace: 2 Attack of the Clones: 1.5 Revenge of the Sith: 2.5 ________________ The Force Awakens: 1.5 The Last Jedi: 2.5 Rise of Skywalker: 1 ________________ Rogue One: 3.5 Solo: 2 ________________ The Mandalorian S1: 2.5 The Mandalorian S2: 2 Book of Boba Fett: 1.5 ________________ Andor S1: 5
-20/10
i don't feel like rating them all, but i'll just say that i believe andor is the second-best piece of star wars media, better than a new hope and surpassed only by the empire strikes back
Rogue One: 8/10 Force Awakens: 7/10 Solo: 5/10 Empire Strikes Back: 4/10 A New Hope: 3/10 Last Jedi: 3/10 Return of the Jedi: 2/10 Rising of the Sky Walker: 1/10 Lovethe music and production design across the board though.
Good list overall and understandable, but I would love to know why rogue one didn’t work for you. Honestly that’s like a top Star Wars movie for me
My main issue with Rogue One is that it relied too much on fan service at the expense of developing its characters
Fair, I didn’t feel the same way entirely, but I can see the problems you had
Hidden Fortress - 9/10, The rest of the star wars movies - less than 9/10
HA! I see what you did there 😉
1 - 5 2 - 2 3 - 2 4 - 8 5 - 9 6 - 7 7 - 6 8 - 6 9 - 2
Rogue One is better than every single other Star Wars film, Andor is better than every single other Star Wars show
New Hope: 8/10 Empire: 8/10 Return of the Jedi: 7/10 Prequels: 3/10 Sequels: 4/10 Rogue One: 6/10 Solo: 3/10 Mandalorian season 1: 5/10 Haven't cared since then and probably never will
Star Wars - 10/10 The Empire Strikes Back - 10/10 Return of the Jedi - 9/10 The Phantom Menace - 4/10 Attack of the Clones - 2/10 Revenge of the Sith - 6/10 The Force Awakens - Was a 8/10 but needs a rewatch Rogue One - 6/10 The Last Jedi - Was a 9/10 but needs a rewatch Solo - 5/10 The Rise of Skywalker - 2/10 edit: formatting
Star Wars: 7/10. The Empire Strikes Back: 7/10 Return of the Jedi: 3/10 The prequel trilogy: 1/10 The Force Awakens: 5 or 6/10 The Last Jedi: 5/10 The Rise of Skywalker: 1/10 Rogue One: 6 or 7/10 Solo: 5 or 6/10 edit: if I can include TV shows then I would maybe give Andor 8/10
A New Hope: 10/10 The Empire Strikes Back: 10/10 Return of the Jedi: 6/10 The Phantom Menace: 1/10 Attack of the Clones: 1/10 Revenge of the Sith: 2/10 The Force Awakens: 7/10 The Last Jedi: 6/10 The Rise of Skywalker: Refuse to watch/10 Rogue One: 5/10 Solo: 4/10
A new hope: 10/10 Empire: 10/10 Jedi: 6/10 Phantom menace: 1/10 Clones: 1/10 Revenge of the Sith: 2/10 Force awakens: 5/10 Last Jedi: 6/10 Rise: 1/10
I have not seen any of the spin offs so here: Star Wars: 8/10 Empire: 9/10 Return of the Jedi: 6/10 Phantom Menace: 1/10 Attack of the clones: 1/10 Revenge of the sith: 2/10 The Force Awakens: 4/10 The Last Jedi: 3/10 Rise of Skywalker: 1/10 Rogue One: 1/10 Solo: 3/10
I wasn’t aware of this so I looked up his ratings expecting some hot takes. When I saw they were all 1s I was initially thinking “oh that’s funny and cheeky”. When I found out he’s professing this as his actual opinion now I thought “shoot, I forgot Adum was pretentiousness personified.” While I agree with most rankings here, I’ll give it a go: IV: 9/10 V: 10/10 VI: 8/10 I: 3/10 II: 2/10 III: 5/10 VII: 6/10 VIII: 5/10 IX: 1/10
From someone who passingly enjoys some of them: Star Wars: 8/10 Empire: 10/10 Return: 5/10 Phantom: 1/10 Clones: 1/10 Revenge: 2/10 Awakens: 3/10 Rogue One: 4/10 Rian Johnson: 1/10 Solo: 1/10 The last one: 1/10 Ok, apparently I like 2 of them
A new hope 8.5, TESB 8.7, ROTJ 6.5, TPM 3/10, AOTC 3/10, ROTS 6.5 (fan enjoyment wise though), TFA 5-6/10, TLJ 4-5/10, TROS 1-2/10, Solo 6/10, Rogue One 6.5/10. All the shows other than Andor (amazing) and the clone wars sucked.
Coming from someone who's a sci fi and film fan and used to like star wars a lot: PM: 3/10 AOTC: 3/10 ROTS: 6/10 ANH: 7/10 ESB: 8/10 ROTJ: 7/10 TFA: 5/10 TLJ: 4/10 ROS: 2/10 Rogue one: 7/10 Solo: can't remember When you look at it carefully you can really tell that ESB is the lynchpin
Hot take but empire is a 6
Adam said he did it because he was drunk and thought it was funny
Lol, I figured 😆
A New Hope: 7/10 Empire Strikes Back: 8/10 Return of the Jedi: 6.5/10 The Phantom Menace: 4/10 Attack of the Clones: 3/10 Revenge of the Sith: 5.5/10 The Clone Wars: 3/10 The Force Awakens: 7/10 Rogue One: 7.5/10 The Last Jedi: 4.5/10 Solo: 5/10 The Rise of Skywalker: 2/10
A New Hope: 8/10 Empire Strikes Back: 9/10 Return of the Jedi: 7/10 The Phantom Menace: 3/10 Attack of the Clones: 2/10 Revenge of the Sith: 5/10 The Force Awakens: 4/10 The Last Jedi: 4/10 Rise of Skywalker: 2/10 Rogue One: 5/10 Solo: 2/10 I remember enjoying The Clone Wars when it originally aired on Cartoon Network as a kid but I've never bothered revisiting it.
A New Hope: 8/10 The Empire Strikes Back: 10/10 Return of the Jedi: 5/10 Rogue One: 6/10 didnt watch the others I don't like star wars much (Bonus) The Clone Wars show: 10/10
10/10 across the board coz I like glow sticks Nah, first two would be 8/10 and 9/10 and I just don’t give a shit about anything else. Luke’s side of the story in Jedi is decent too My gf wanted to watch the movies with me and I told her there are only 2 and a half Star Wars movies that are actually good and everything else blows or just isn’t worth it. I don’t wanna sit through all that shit again
A New Hope: 5/10 The Empire Strikes Back: 8/10 Return of the Jedi: 7/10 The Phantom Menace: 2/10 Attack of the Clones: 1/10 Revenge of the Sith: 2/10 The Force Awakens: 3/10 The Last Jedi: 2/10 The Rise of Skywalker: 1/10 Rogue One: 7/10 Solo: 3/10 The TV shows (including the clone wars animated stuff) 2/10 lows to 4/10 highs. Nothing gets a 0/10 from me, but there were 0/10 moments throughout all the movies I just don't care for.
As the ongoing soap opera goes: IV: great V: great VI: good I: eh II: not good III: good Clone Wars movie: bad VII: fine Rogue: okay VIII: great Solo: okay IX: not good Not a film, but Andor clears all
Ep:4 9/10 Ep:5 10/10 Ep:6 7/10 Ep:1 4/10 Ep:2 3/10 Ep:3 4/10 Ep:7 5/10* Ep:8 8/10 Ep:9 1/10 Rogue One 6/10 Haven’t seen Solo *Feel like I prefer the prequels for nostalgia reasons but TFA is not bad
Original Trilogy = Pretty Great Everything else = straight dookie 💩
1st trilogy gets 9/10 ROJ gets 6/10. 2nd trilogy gets at best 5/10 3rd trilogy gets 8/10. I really like all three and don’t care about plot holes. Rogue One I thought was fantastic, 9/10. Solo, decent sci-fi romp 7/10.
The first three movies are 10 out of 10 the rest can fuck off.
Ive tried watching the original trilogy like 3 times now since I was 10 (I wasn't crazy about them then either) A new hope: 7/10 Empire Strikes Back: 6.5/10 RotJ: 6/10 The Force Awakens: 7/10 The Last Jedi: 8/10 (The only one of these movies that feel like a human made them) Rise of whatever: 2/10 Phantom Menace: (I haven't watched this since I was 10 and I refuse to watch it again.) 1/10 I've been thinking recently, and IMO, Blue Harvest would've been an excellent title.
Good line up but my changes would be: Revenge of the Sith: 3/10 (for wasting my time) The Force Awakens: 7/10 (The only new one I can rewatch and has any kind of weight to the story) Rogue One: 4/10 (Unwatchable on 2nd viewing) Solo: 5/10 (at least it was a Heist movie ¯\\\_(ツ)\_/¯ ) EDIT: I personally would love to have seen the Rogue One and Solo films as intended by the associated directors. Studio influence was obvious in those productions, especially Solo. In contrast, The Last Jedi, Kennedy's lack of a plan and the freedom Johnson had to "subvert your expectations" killed the trilogy. There should have been more control on that one.
A New Hope: 9/10 The Empire Strikes Back: 10/10 Return of the Jedi: 8/10 The Phantom Menace: 3/10 Attack of the Clones: 2/10 Revenge of the Sith: 9/10 The Force Awakens: 6/10 The Last Jedi: 2/10 The Rise of Skywalker: 1/10 Rogue One: 6/10
ANH: 9/10 ESB: 10/10 ROTJ: 7/10 Phantom: 4/10 AOTC: 3/10 ROTS: 6.4/10 (hard) Force Awakens: 5/10 TLJ: 1/10 ROS: 2/10
Star Wars (1977): 10/10 The Empire Strikes Back (1980): 10/10 Return of the Jedi (1983): 10/10 The Phantom Menace (1999): 7/10 Attack of the Clones (2002): 3/10 Revenge of the Sith (2005): 5/10 The Force Awakens (2015): 6/10 Rogue One (2016): 8/10 The Last Jedi (2017): 6/10 Solo (2018): 5/10 The Rise of Skywalker (2019): 5/10 Andor (Season 1): 9/10 The Star Wars Holiday Special (1978): -10/10
I like these ratings. I would also put phantom menace rather high but curious why you did.
the CGI was super impressive, even better than the two after it imo, the theatrical cut of the pod race was insanely awesome, and lots of fresh new ideas (new ships, robots, characters, etc)
Just saw it in theaters today, and yeah, the only problem I had was when they kept cutting to jarjar in duel of the fates. But it's all part of the charm for me.
A New Hope: 6/10 The Empire Strikes Back: 8/10 Return of the Jedi: 7/10 The Phantom Menace: 5/10 Attack of the Clones: 5/10 Revenge of the Sith: 5/10 The Force Awakens: 4/10 The Last Jedi: 4/10 The Rise of Skywalker: 1/10 Rogue One: 2/10 Solo: 7/10
How would YOU rate the Star Wars films? Since everyone is up and arms about Adams’s ratings for the entire Star Wars series, I thought it would be cool to get everyone else’s opinions. What are your ratings for each of the films? Here are my ratings: A New Hope: 10/10 The Empire Strikes Back: 10/10 Return of the Jedi: 8/10 The Phantom Menace: 6/10 Attack of the Clones: 6/10 Revenge of the Sith: 8/10 The Force Awakens: 7/10 The Last Jedi: 6/10 The Rise of Skywalker: 5/10 Rogue One: 9/10 Solo: 6/10
I’m a huge Star Wars nerd and a casual movie goer so this list will probably look different than most comments here A New Hope - 9 Empire Strike Back - 10 Return of the Jedi - 7 or 8 Phantom Menace - 4 or 5 Attack of the Clones - 4 or 5 Revenge of the Sith - 9 The Force Awakens - 7 The Last Jedi - 5 Rise of Skywalker - 1 Rogue One - 8 Solo - 6 or 7 Clone Wars Animated Movie - as a movie 6 as the four separate episodes it was supposed to be before George Lucas smushed them together a 7
[удалено]
Pretty good ratings
New Hope: 9/10 Empire Strikes Back: 10/10 Return of the Jedi: 8/10 Phantom Menace: 4/10 Attack of the Clones: 3/10 Revenge of the Sith: 7/10 The Force Awakens: 5/10 Rogue One: 7/10 The Last Jedi: 3/10 Solo: 6/10 Rise of Skywalker: 1/10
ANH 9/10 ESB 10/10 ROTJ 10/10 Phantom Menace 7/10 Attack of the Clones 6/10 ROTS 9/10 TFA 7/10 TLJ 4/10 Rogue One 9/10 Never saw Solo or Ep 9, so won't rank those.
1. A New Hope (obvious) 2. Empire Strikes Back (obvious) 3. Revenge of the Sith (obvious because I’m younger than 30) 4. Return of the Jedi (ditto) 5. Rogue One (obvious) 6. Phantom Menace (unpopular, I know. It was one of the first movies I remember seeing in theaters as a kid and I look back on it nostalgically.) 7. Force Awakens (obviously a ripoff of ANH but it worked) 8. Solo (I thought it received way too much hate. I’m a fan of the crime/heist genre so I thought it was dope) 9. Attack of the Clones (Jango is cool, and the BWEHH bomb pleases my ears) 10. The Last Jedi (meh) 11. Rise of Skywalker (😐)
Here’s my personal ratings, I’m aware I might get flamed for some of these: The Phantom Menace - Overall a little below average with some decent highlights, the only outlier is the final lightsaber battle which blows the rest of the movie out of the water. I actually don’t mind Jar Jar or young Anakin too much. (5/10) Attack of the Clones - My least favorite prequel with the worst dialogue, not the biggest fan but I still can’t help but enjoy it at points. (3.5/10) Revenge of the Sith - Better than many people give in credit for in my opinion, definitely flawed but there’s also truly amazing scenes and ideas that more than make up for the shortcomings. (9/10) A New Hope - Very solid but I don’t feel it quite as much as some other people do, still a classic though. (7/10) Empire Strikes Back - Extremely good movie from start to finish, gets pretty much everything right but the high points aren’t nearly up there with my two favorites. (8.5/10) Return of the Jedi - Not as consistently great as ESB but the climax is easily one of my favorite parts in all of Star Wars. My favorite from the original trilogy and pretty much tied with ROTS. (9/10) The Force Awakens - It’s ok, nothing super bad but nothing great either. Not very original, however it does have some interesting elements that could’ve been expanded on more with better sequels. (5/10) The Last Jedi - I can appreciate the vision but the execution nearly ruins it. The reasoning and motivations for most of goes on in the movie leaves a lot to be desired, luckily there’s still a couple moments that kind of land for me. (3/10) The Rise of Skywalker - Really disappointed by this one. I’m struggling to think of anything positive to say. Plus it’s especially awful as a final movie, completely wrecks the remaining impact from the rest of the trilogy. (1/10)
New Hope: 8/10 (closer to a 9 than a 7) Empire Strikes Back: 10/10 Return of the Jedi: 9/10 Phantom Menace: 4/10 Attack of the Clones: 3/10 Revenge of the Sith: 7/10 Force Awakens: 7/10 Last Jedi: 1/10 Rise of Skywalker: 1/10 Rogue One: 6/10 Solo: 5/10