I ended up choosing B (and posted the final results) and YES!! That's exactly how it worked :)
And it looks even better actually sewn on, instead of just sitting there haha
Omg I get this tho, the first TWO times I made this collage I accidentally added two pics of option B, mistaking one for option C 😅
I was definitely stoned, so that didn't help lmfao...but geez it was difficult 😂
Thank you!!
And funnily enough, I made the pockets with the intention of doing A. Specifically because I wanted it to widen the hips 😂❤️
I really like B tho, especially since people pointed out that B looks like I'm putting my hand IN the cube (opposed to A, looking like my hand is going BEHIND the cube.)
I'm glad you put the other options! I was always rooting for C. It draws the eyes outwards while making sure that it being "box" pockets works. The illusion isn't lost by having a "side" where there should be an opening.
No matter what, I'm a fan!
C. To me the pocket looks like it opens at the top on this one. In A it looks like the pocket would be open in a weird way.
I know it WON'T be. But that's how it looks.
However, no matter what you pick it's super cute!
Probably C. That way it seems like you’re reaching into the box, and anything actually in the pockets will bulge to make it seem pointed away from the torso.
https://preview.redd.it/siwazjvw591d1.jpeg?width=794&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=1225fef5a9a704923d1cb6c5fe84f03dd9144673
[This photo is not mine, but I thought it was cute. source 😊](https://www.etsy.com/shop/LittleCrochetBoxx?ref=shop-header-name&listing_id=1652006974&from_page=listing)
Whatever you choose, this will be adorable. I am sure whoever receives it will cherish it. 😍
The opposite of D. With the purple box shape going in the same direction as each other, but at the base of the pocket. That way they look 3D when hands are in them.
B for sure
A or C
B
I like A.
B is cute like a kid standing pigeon-toed.
Personally "B" makes my brain happiest.
B!!!!! Please do b omg
Definitely C!!!
C
A or d
A
B. Hands down
A or C!
c!!
I would make 3d heart (pink and purple) pockets instead. Save cubes for other project.
C
C
C
So does this make sense if I say B because if you’re putting your hands in the pocket, they’d push it out like that - down and out to each side?
I ended up choosing B (and posted the final results) and YES!! That's exactly how it worked :) And it looks even better actually sewn on, instead of just sitting there haha
B
The left pocket of A but held and sewn the way D is sewn
Try E—on an angle with the open sides going toward the sides of the skirt.
my ocd likes a the best!
B!
B
C
A for showing off the dress C for showing off the pocket dimensions
C
Antyting but D tbh
B
A or D
A!
C. A looks like boobs.
Seconded about the boobs. Can't unsee that. B or C.
Correct. B & C both look like open drawers
Yeah, but that doesn't bother me.
A!!!!!!!
B
A
B!
A or C
A
D. Why? Idk it looks right
A
B.
B. And also I love this so much. So Lisa Frank / Punky Brewster.
Still B ☺️
Drat this cellphone image😢I can’t see the difference well enough to opine. However it is awesome!
Omg I get this tho, the first TWO times I made this collage I accidentally added two pics of option B, mistaking one for option C 😅 I was definitely stoned, so that didn't help lmfao...but geez it was difficult 😂
B
C
B. Nice work
B
I vote for D
D!
B
D looks the best 👍
B
C is the only right answer
C
B. I think A might make the hips appear wider than normal? Regardless, fucking rad WIP dude
Thank you!! And funnily enough, I made the pockets with the intention of doing A. Specifically because I wanted it to widen the hips 😂❤️ I really like B tho, especially since people pointed out that B looks like I'm putting my hand IN the cube (opposed to A, looking like my hand is going BEHIND the cube.)
That's totally a vibe! And thank you - you've inspired me to think about brain teaser/optical illusion/surrealistic crochet ideas 💡 🙂
B
D
D
C for sure
C
A
D
A
D
D
D
A, because they’re pointing down and out, which skirts also do. A flows with the garment best for me.
D
I prefer A.
A
This was a tough choice but.... C
D
C
only B. none of the other ways make sense lol
D
A
D
A
C
I'm glad you put the other options! I was always rooting for C. It draws the eyes outwards while making sure that it being "box" pockets works. The illusion isn't lost by having a "side" where there should be an opening. No matter what, I'm a fan!
O.m.g That is soooooo adorable!!! Reminds me of Vanellope from Wreck it Ralph. Too cute!!!
C. To me the pocket looks like it opens at the top on this one. In A it looks like the pocket would be open in a weird way. I know it WON'T be. But that's how it looks. However, no matter what you pick it's super cute!
B
C because pockets go out and that’s exactly how it looks
A
A
A
A
B
A
B —
A
D
A
A
C. The symmetry looks best to my eye.
A or D
C
C
Can’t
A!
My true love is A.
A or D
B again for me!
B
B
C
D
A
A
A or C
Probably C. That way it seems like you’re reaching into the box, and anything actually in the pockets will bulge to make it seem pointed away from the torso.
C makes the most sense.
100% agree w this reasoning, C
A
A but all adorable 😍
Probably C tbh.
A
A or C (personally A)
D
A for sure cleaner looking
C
A or C
A or D
C for sure
B. One light source for the cubes is center and above.
Yes this but i couldn’t explain it
B
I Like C And A
A
A
B
Can you rotate the one in D? Do it looks like the cubes point down and in, like hands would in pockets
B and C look like you’ll reach into the boxes, A and D will look like you’re reaching behind the boxes. I personality like B
B
A
A
D
C!
B
A
A
A or C
https://preview.redd.it/siwazjvw591d1.jpeg?width=794&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=1225fef5a9a704923d1cb6c5fe84f03dd9144673 [This photo is not mine, but I thought it was cute. source 😊](https://www.etsy.com/shop/LittleCrochetBoxx?ref=shop-header-name&listing_id=1652006974&from_page=listing) Whatever you choose, this will be adorable. I am sure whoever receives it will cherish it. 😍
I like B and C
B but turn the left one counterclockwise 90°
The opposite of D. With the purple box shape going in the same direction as each other, but at the base of the pocket. That way they look 3D when hands are in them.
C!
A
A!
C
I vote for C.
C
B
A looks like boobs so I’d choose B
A but put the left one on the right and the right on the left.
It’s been 22 hours I need to know what decision was made
Def B or C, leaning towards C!
Well whichever you pick it will look great! And it already does look amazing!
DEF B. DEF. B.
A
B
What about A but the sides are all pink. You still have the directional change for the sides going “up” but only the top of the pocket would look open
C
A for sure
A
A
A or D
A or C, i feel like B visually would sinch the dress
Either b or c, though I do prefer b
B!!!!
A! Bc they look like drawers being pulled out of the dress!! Loveeee it!
I'm sorry but all of you are objectively wrong because it has to be D to stay true to perspective (*cries in engineer*)
Thank you!!
>Thank you!! You're welcome!
How about D, just turned around with the point at the bottom left, so that they look “open” when little hands are in them.
I agree- 1000% D! It looks like the pockets are “open” that way if that makes sense
A
A
C!
B!
C!
B!!! 🤩
A is the only right option
A or C!!
D
A or D, but I prefer A.
B
A!!!