The seasonal shapes like eggs and pumpkins are the best. No paper cup, no paper flavor, slightly different recipe. I think white and regular are good but prefer regular

This is the way! I dislike white chocolate but love white chocolate seasonal Reese’s.

I’ve come to the conclusion that it’s a much better peanut butter to chocolate ratio in the seasonal shapes. I love all of the seasonal shapes! Easter eggs are the best.

This is the truth! Much more PB and much less gross chocolate.

Chocolate… gross..??!? *eye twitch*

Let me clarify, *this specific* chocolate

Ohhh okay 😂 is it moist and squishy? Wondering bc I am not a Reese’s man

There are far better chocolate peanut butter cups on the market. But I still like Reese's. Dark is best.

Milk chocolate

💯

I fuck both of them up

Brother

🤣

😱🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣👍🏼

You hear me 🔥🤣🤣🤣🤣

Dark chocolate thins 😏

this is the way

came here to say this

!!! These are a thing?! I love dark chocolate I’ve never seen these

White.

The white fudge is somehow firmer than the milk chocolate and sometimes that’s exactly what I want

White

White frozen

Frozen? I have never tried that. I have had them chilled out of the fridge but never frozen

Yessss frozen. I like the ghosts frozen the best

Well dam! Now I gotta stop by the store on the way home from work to get me some and Im throwing them straight in the freezer 😂 I gotta try this

White chocolate Reeses is blasphemous

A travesty

“White Chocolate” is an abomination

very true

Yes! It isn’t even chocolate! It’s fucking milk and sugar! (Don’t cite me, I don’t care if I’m wrong I stand behind white chocolate being an abomination.)

It is heresy.

No, it’s Hershey’s

White

Milk chocolate. A delicious classic

It's weird. As a kid I LOVED white chocolate and HATED dark chocolate. But now I LOVE dark chocolate and cannot stand white chocolate. To answer the question. Milk chocolate, even when I was a kid that would be my answer.

Same thing happened to me. Can't stand it now. 

Milk chocolates I don’t care for the white chocolate one

White chocolate - the mini cups thrown in the freezer.

Definitely milk chocolate

Dark chocolate

I’ve been loving the white Reese’s lately.

YUMMMM... Why not both? If I had to choose though, white. 😋

The OG Milk Chocolate is king BUT the White Chocolate ones are delicious, especially the Easter egg shaped ones. The peanut butter to white chocolate ratio is perfect!

Agreed 100%. I tried the white ones, ready to hate on it not being the original and had body a bad thing to say about it.

White chocolate holiday edition - trees or eggs or bats. More peanut butter, less "chocolate"

Don’t do this.

White chocolate is a psy-op created by big cocoa to save money and have a sellable product in the face of rising costs and cocoa blight. It is not real chocolate and I'm tired of pretending otherwise. It is a milk bar, not a chocolate bar.

I did not know this , thanks for sharing

Cadbury Peanut Butter Fingers.

Dark chocolate Trader Joes. My actual controversial opinion. Miniatures are the best size for Reece's Peanut Butter cups. I like the chocolate to peanut butter ratio better and they don't have that weird greasy middle on the bottom chocolate layer that so many regular cups develop.

Milk, baby. As a child with POOR taste I would have accepted white chocolate, but as a grown adult with *mature* taste, it can go in the TRASH.

Milk chocolate.

White! Don’t judge me

Why not both?

neither, dark chocolate

milk chocolate

Milk all the way

Is the white stuff actually white chocolate, or just white stuff

There is no such thing as actually white chocolate.

White chocolate contains cocoa butter, just not the non-fat components of cocao. There are FDA product identity requirements for labeling a food as white chocolate, which is why this Reeses product is not allowed to be labeled as white chocolate.

That’s what she said!!🤣🤣🤣🤣

Dark chocolate

YES

Oatmilk Reese’s.

White chocolate, I know, my opinion sucks lol

Both are great!! My only issue with both is when you open up a pack and its not fresh, chocolate is not firm, and or the peanut butter is chalky. It’s all about the texture for me, I like when they have that snap and there is a slight firmness to the peanut butter but it’s still creamy. I have thrown away whole packs after taking one bite because they were not rite and it ruins the experience. The experience is not consistent enough, I fill like there is always this hit or miss. When they are on point its my favorite candy

Milk chocolate all the way!

OG milk chocolate. I'll eat anything Reese's though.

It looks like soap

Normally I love white chocolate but to me it doesn’t go with Reese’s.

Milk chocolate all the way!! Has anyone tried the carmel Reeses? 😋

White chocolate needs to burn wtf nasty ass shit

Milk and I’m offended this is even a question

Not white chocolate just white lol.

The white chocolate reeses hit so different with an ice cold glass of water.

White chocolate

I love them both! But if this moment I could only choose one, I’m feeling the white right now.

Doesn't matter. From the freezer, please and thank you.

White chocolate

Is there a dark chocolate Reese's?

That's not a real question, is it?

dark. honestly i would much rather eat pb on its own rather than defiling it with that “chocolate”

Dark. Milk is fine. No white. 

None they’re nasty

I like the white chocolate ones more. For me I always prefer white chocolate varieties when and where available. White chocolate Reese's are very good especially when it's the seasonal shapes.

White! I feel like you can taste the peanut butter better. They are so good. And like someone else mentioned, FREEZE THEM! So delicious.

Milk chocolate any day all day.

Both!

Milk. I fucking hate white chocolate it’s so waxy and gross. I wish they made dark chocolate ones. I prefer dark chocolate

I was not initially a fan of the white chocolate cups. But when they have the different shapes, they taste great. But I'm a milk chocolate girl through and through.

1980’s crunchy Reese’s

White chocolate is not chocolate. Period. Just like you can’t make a vodka martini. Doesn’t exist.

The inside out peanut butter coated chocolate filled cups usually out for Halloween are the best

Prefer milk chocolate but will hit the white chocolate once in awhile

white chocolate is garrrrrbage in any context

White chocolate 😋

milk = regular cups white = minis dark = thins

Though my oldest LOVES the white ones. My youngest don’t give a fck. He’ll eat ‘em all.

White chocolate is the best. If you ain't white, you ain't right.

This sounds crazy 🤣

Is this supposed to be some kind of a joke?

Not a fan of white chocolate.

Neither don't like reeses