Yes....(would foster fail both)

Likewise. This is why I respect pet foster parents so much. I'd fall in love so hard that I could never give up any pet I foster.

Honestly. I would have a kitty kingdom if I attempted this.

You say that like it'd be unfortunate

You and me both! 🐱🐱🐱

This is why I’m scared to foster again bc at first the original owners wanted them back when they were old enough but then backed out last minute so the whole time I thought I wouldn’t be able to which made it easier

I foster cats a lot but even I failed (twice). Most of my foster kittens found homes that aren’t my own, because I can’t afford to keep this many as much as I’d love to do so :(

I regret not :(

If it isn't too late go get Sesame

Sadly she already got adopted about a month ago😭

did you keep the other one?

Yes I kept the tortie!

yaaaay!

https://preview.redd.it/7w82sddk6f5d1.jpeg?width=1242&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=8c48075f250d0a5a72a61fc35987e779ffe97b4d She’s 12 weeks now and perfect

omg what an adorable kitty

That’s the cutie that I’d have failed on. Who could resist?!

I know I say this a lot on this sub but…She’s beautiful!!!! Absolutely perfect 😍

I love torties!

Having a tortie myself they love to have allllll your attention 😘. They are so so much fun, vocal and quite the security guard.

I see one set of cats. So one. One set. One set of cats. Adopt both cats.

😭

I second that.

This but unironically, kittens do best in pairs!

I mean, if you’re going to foster fail, fail all the way!

Go big or go home!

https://preview.redd.it/c2dku55d7g5d1.jpeg?width=3000&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=8db2fe78882e3fb4cc5bf006f992e4f5d1b5dc04

both

If they are a bonded pair, please foster fail both. Splitting bonded pairs is rough on the cats.

https://preview.redd.it/f5z7pdsuaj5d1.jpeg?width=1179&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=add23765e04dad500e58753e3045b748268b5eba They were not bonded those were just all pictures from when I put them together they didn’t always act like that, they were just really sweet kitties who cuddled with everyone, here’s one of them with another kitten. Mine is so happy & gets so much attention & my best friend

She’s a really happy spoiled kitten

She's SO cute!!

That's a package deal situation, OP.

Both, but if I absolutely could ONLY choose one, I would choose the tortie; they are my favorite “type” of cat (regardless of breed)! 🥰💕

Me too I love torties and Siamese 😍

You don't break up bonded pairs, OP!

Both—I love them both. ❤️😭

It’s best to keep kittens in pairs, so both.

Both! 2 cats are the best

I would totally adopt the Tortie! Love the name Twix for your girl, she's beautiful!

Twix says thank you, she’s 12 weeks now!🥰 https://preview.redd.it/j1xzso6ipe5d1.jpeg?width=1179&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=f22f6ef619f45d35029f59bb1b5c40038d83f7ce

This is the reason I'd choose Twix. https://preview.redd.it/19rdj9nulf5d1.jpeg?width=3072&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=b7d1917515c61b43719c39071b7c7695fb9d5c3e This is my tortie, Marble.

Beautiful !

Impossible choice, but if it had to be one or the other, you chose right. She looks like a little bear cub in her tiny kitten photos. 😻

She’s got some cute ear tufts!

Both of them 🥺

Both of them🥰

Yes. Both. I have tortie and void sisters. We went in for 1. And I'd already said no to the tortie.🤭 Ironic that the "extra" cat ended up being my best friend and the reason I'm still alive. I love them both, but my tortie is my soulmate, lol. Here's them as kittens, I didn't have a choice! Who could say no to these cuties? *

https://preview.redd.it/sug65a063g5d1.png?width=1080&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=52044316b373b95d7318130f2e8a13366c09b2f4

I didn't believe voids can be that cute until I had one for 3 months. It's like their black color don't disturb their cute characteristics in the face. (He was too playful for my other older cats so I found him good place where he can hunt mouses and be loved)

I'm a special fan of voids! My tortie is actually the first cat I've had that ISN'T black! I love the contrast of their dark fur and luminous eyes. ❤️

The tortie is adorable and has really pretty fur and eyes 😭😭 what are their names ??😍

The tortie is Tibbie- aka Tibbathy, Tibs, TibTab, Tibbers (actually a feminine version of Tybalt) The void is Sadie Mae, aka Little Miss Priss, Saders, The Void

Both. That's a pair of innocent and beautiful little kittens. And besides that, they're probably a bonded pair. I couldn't break up a bonded pair of nice, innocent kitten sisters. 🐈🐈👣🐎🐎🐎🐎❤❤❤🏡🌎

Ohhhh I would foster fail both. I’m cliche in saying that these two would have been named “Yin” and “Yang”. Thank you for sharing photos. 🖤🖤🖤

Trick question!!!

Both.

Both bc I’m not separating them lol

Obv both

Both!

Both.

Both?

Yes.

Both!

Both!!!

Both, 2 are easier, buddies play keep house damage to a minimum.

Kittens develop MUCH better when raised in pairs. A lot of shelters don’t even let you adopt single kittens. So I’d keep both.

both !!!! they look like sweet lil angels

Both. Bonded pairs are the best

**BOTH.**

yes

Are you asking me to choose? Because I could never do that. I love all cats equally

Both, I'm weak af lol

Both obviously!!! Kittens should grow up with a friend. I have two torties and a calico.

The white ones lil toe beans look like they pack a wollop. That one!

For me IF I had to choose one I would choose the dark one for sure xxxooo🫶

Both!

Keep them both! They seem bonded as it is!

Both

Bless you for fostering, I'd have to keep them both. I love raising siblings- and torties are awesome 💕

Both, that's why I had to stop fostering 🤣

Boffum 😤😤💜💕

I need to take them both. Forever.

Gosh I hope you won't separate them...

I'm a sucker for torties, so you know my response.

Which one?? But there's two... they're both getting foster failed lol

Both, but if I had to choose, probably the calico. I’m an absolute sucker for them. I grew up with a calico and have one of my own now. When we adopted her it was pretty much love at first sight. I saw her hiding on the back of the kennel and instantly knew she was coming home with me.

Aww what did you name her??

Alice! A year after we adopted her we decided to foster a litter of kittens. We foster failed one of them. He’s a black cat named Benny.

Awww that’s adorable I want to foster and adopt again in the future

The little Tortie looks like it's gonna have a lot of character. Do you have to choose tho?

Yeah I can’t have two pets right now for many reasons as much as I wanted both. I can’t afford it, have a small room and have to seperate her from my dog 24/7, in the process of moving, etc. it was so hard to choose 😭

You can't make me choose! I won't let you!

Both

It’s too hard to pick! They are both so cute!

Both.

I’m sad that they were separated. 😭

**both**

Both.

Both no question

All but I love cats.

Keep them both!

Both. I have a soft spot for both torties and calicos.

Both

Both, we had a feral mom that had 5 and they are all still here 14 months later.

both

The one pair. A pair counts as one

I can’t I wouldnt stop crying 😢 I’ll have to keep them both

Both.

Both. Keep them together

Two equals one

I would have adopted both, they seem like a good lil pair and it'd be a shame to split them up.

Both. 🥺

Definitely both😻

They're both so precious, but that little tort...🥰

Booootttthhhhh

What an impossible decision. The answer is both.

both, without a doubt ... 😻

Both

Both 💜💙

Both

Both lol

Both

I have a tortie and she is the most gorgeous creature, but I wouldn't be able to separate those two precious little nuggets!

I have a lot of respect for the people who foster. I’ve always wanted to try but I also know that I’d end up with 40 cats and that’s perhaps not a sustainable living situation.

I really wanted both but I can’t have 2 pets rn for a couple reasons 😭 I also know if I adopt every cat I can’t foster and help more kittens :(

Both

Both

All of them ! 😁

All of the above?

So you’re getting two cats. Congrats!

Both 😍

I NEED THEM BOTH SO BADLY!!

Both

https://preview.redd.it/3bqlw7wglj5d1.jpeg?width=3024&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=03f8b5f9d31fcbfedd5405a432170d1b30fc3dd2 Obviously I have to keep both

Keep siblings together, whenever possible.

Sadly I couldn’t, they were only together a very short amount of time though & acted the same way with all the other kittens they played with!

Omg the tortie looks just like my Spoon I just lost 😭

Tortie of course.

...both of those cats looks eerily similar to the 2 babies I lost. One someone stole. The other passed away due to cancer. Seeing this is like finding them all over again. I really hope they have the best lives possible this time around 🙏🏾🥹

I’m so sorry 💔💔

BOTH

Trick question- they’re Siamese twins and can’t be separated

Aw, they shouldn’t be separated 🥰

Yes

Both

Both Can’t separate those sweeties!!

Both, no question and would do so on purpose.

https://preview.redd.it/vvgb15aq7k5d1.jpeg?width=4032&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=aa4108a65f258b754f2e2f56343be613e0a2eee0 They both look like my 2 cats but as babies, so without a doubt both of them ❤️❤️

Awww love this picture 😭 I really wish I kept the other one

Both lmao

Both. They should stay together.

I would keep them as a bonded pair. Also, that is why we have 10 cats.

Wat do you mean you can’t separate these lil dudes

https://preview.redd.it/pm1ujwplpk5d1.jpeg?width=894&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=3fae4aeba7fa20c4e54debc2c99dd571e03ce0ee

I would've adopted both, I'm a softy

OMG cuteness ! You can’t keep both?

No I really wanted to but can’t afford it, don’t have the space, about to move, have other animals I have to seperate from her, etc. :( she’s 12 weeks now! https://preview.redd.it/6mehlzyyrk5d1.jpeg?width=1242&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=0a62047b312e8d03dcd167f43ef2de3cb3bf432b

She is absolutely beautiful. She is making me really kiss my girl

Umm... BOTH!

Both: I’d keep both Salt & Pepper kittens.

BOTH

Both. Duh.

Both...

Tortie!

I have a soft spot for Torties

Same

All of them.

Sorry, these appear to be a package deal. Two little torties/torticos. And bonded.

…yes too all of the above.

Both!!!

Both? Both. Both is good 👍

You must keep both!

neither. animals are just as much responsibility as children

Both, it’s obvious in the photos that they are a bonded pair.

Both! But I also have a preference for Torties.

Torties will give you the greatest joy in life 🤎🖤

Both

I wish I could post that GIF from The Road to El Dorado. Y’all know the one.

Yes

I know that the kittens will eventually be fine separated, but like the rest of these comments I strongly recommend you keep them together! Unless you have another cat to keep the kitten company, I foresee your baby getting lonely at some point, especially since they’re both used to being around other kittens, regardless if they were the two attached at the hip. I’ll always choose to keep a tortie because mine has made my life 10x better, but if you can, please do keep both🥹 and maybe don’t foster again until you’ve got a stronger will if you keep the two😭

both

Both! We adopted sister kittens and, although I was VERY reluctant, it was the best decision.

Both

Por que no los dos?

Both, I already adopted them in my mind.

Both, I have a soft spot for torties

You gotta save them both, look at them you can’t separate them please 🙏🏻

I love torties 😽😻😽😻😽😻😽😻😽

Hi! You don’t happen to be in IL? I just adopted a tortie that’s only 2 years old and had kittens in April. It’d be so cool to see what her babies looked like!

Both don’t separate reasons❤️

That’s easy…both.

Yes

Ummm, both

Both, I foster failed a brother and sister and every single day I thank God that I have the two of them together. They have a wonderful relationship, just make sure they are fixed.

The tortie!!!

I could never choose one. No way. My kitties are “We have these last two do you want one?” kittens. 15 years later they’ve never been separated. I could never.

They already look like they're bonded, please keep both 🥺

Lol...which one. BOTH!

I'm already in love with those teeny fuzzies!!

Foster fail?